Skip to content

‘Grammar Cop’ and proud of it

Matt Pearl

I was going over a student paper on Monday morning–one of the final papers I ever hope to revise in my teaching role–when I remembered a term I heard years ago that referred to red-pen-wielding individuals like myself:

They call us the Grammar Police. It may (or may not) surprise you to know that this is not a complimentary term in most everyday use.

I have used proofreading marks to suggest changes in student writing for many years now. I was employed at The Writing Center at Northwest Missouri State University when I was a college senior, and I worked in the center for my graduate assistantship in the four semesters following.

Taking red pen to white paper and black ink has been a part of my life since I was in my early 20s. And truthfully, being the son of two English teachers meant that my training at the Pearl Grammar Police Academy began far earlier still.

But I never feel like more of a Grammar Cop than when I read posts on social media that ignore the more basic conventions of spelling and sentence structure.

It’s not that I want to pick up my metaphorical crimson Flair and make online posters miserable: in general, I roll my eyes privately and keep my criticisms to myself. Folks posting on Facebook detest input from the Grammar Police in all forms, and my mission in life is not to lord over others with my experience in proofreading.

Still, the world needs people like me–individuals who hold in high regard the conventions of language and writing. The President, for example, badly needs someone to proofread his Tweets before he sends them out for public scrutiny.

I am not volunteering for that job, in case anyone is interested. Mr. Trump doesn’t strike me as the type of individual who would respond well to being pulled over by the Grammar Patrol. Call it a hunch.

By the way, I fully realize that describing myself as a Grammar Cop will inspire all the other freelance proofreaders out there to begin reading my writing with even closer scrutiny. What can I say? You’re free to go ahead and do so, and I promise that if you read to find my mistakes, you will have plenty of opportunities to do so.

You will find, as I have, that finding mistakes in grammar and writing is like everything else in life: it is much easier to find the flaws in the work of others than to identify your own errors. I can read over the things I write and miss my own mistakes with ease: but I can pick up another newspaper and find typographical errors or misspellings in copy faster than you can say ‘dictionary.’

There is a lesson there pertaining to vanity, self-righteousness and other qualities that we too frequently display as a race. We are so quick to criticize others, yet expect those around us to overlook our flaws. It’s human nature–but not the better side of it.

That being said, I’m fairly sure that my role as a Grammar Cop is one that I will continue to maintain for the remainder of this life. In the execution of the task, however, I plan to demonstrate both fairness and kindness. I only have a month of grading student work before the end of the school year, so my goal should be easily attained in the educational setting.

In terms of social media posts and other non-professional writings, patience is key. I have thus far restrained myself from pointing out errors in the writing of others, and I see no reason why I can’t buckle down and stay true to my pledge. Just a couple of quick reminders: Alot is never a word. It’s should have, not should of. There are no a’s in cemetery. Itch is a noun, and scratch is a verb.

Matt Pearl owns and operates newspapers in King City, Albany, and Grant City.

Leave a Comment