Skip to content

Revisiting narratives of faith and citizenship

Jennifer Ditlevson Haglund

Whenever we visited my cousins, my brothers and sisters gathered around the piano to sing hymns during evening and morning devotions. My immediate family never did this at our house, but corporate singing wasn’t an altogether foreign ritual. We went to church to worship and sang around the fire at church camp.

It wasn’t the singing that bothered me. It was when we got to one song, “Trust and Obey,” that I squirmed. I hated that song.

I’ve never been quick to trust anyone, and obeying sounds too much like taking orders for me to like it. Trust and obedience are so unnatural to me.

I remember wondering if I were a bad girl because I loathed that song so much, but I couldn’t stand for the passivity I presumed that obedience and trust required. Obedience seemed so subservient, conformist, and un-American.

Disobedience defined the United States. I learned this almost as early as I learned to pray. In the name of knowing better, under the guise of justice and the promise of liberty, the colonists killed and died. They preached that pride, strength, and love of personal freedoms put God on their side so that the U.S. flag would fly forever victorious and vindicated. That’s the story I heard, over and over.

The myth of a righteously strong and defiant country excited my imagination, but it also infected how I understood the Gospel message of Christianity.

Christ obeyed his father, lived humbly, and died. His resurrection and glory came after a life of courageously peaceful service and of unflinching yet loving truth, not because of force, coercion, or claims to rights. I was taught to revere and worship Jesus by following that example. Meanwhile, the story of early settlersdisagreeing with the governing authorities, invading territories, stealing things, owning people, and winning secured my country’s success — despite some of the moral problems with all of that.

As I grew, the claims found in the birth legends of my country and of my God conflicted. The more I learned about my ancestry, the more confusing it became. I am the progeny of pioneering settlers, European domestic servants, Confederate as well as Union soldiers, poor immigrant farmers, and indigenous people. My blood is mixed with that of the oppressor and the oppressed.

I can’t change any of the atrocities committed by or to the people who got me here, but the more I read about Christ, the closer I get to being able to tolerate that song written 130 years ago that asks me to do things I don’t like to do. I fight to trust and obey the tenets of Christianity, because they go against my personal preferences and my country’s foundational identity that adopted the view that sometimes you must get your hands dirty to achieve security. That isn’t found in Christ’s teachings. It’s in Machiavelli’s “The Prince,” written in no small part to get Christians more comfortable with the politics of empire-making.

Those same dirty hands that did what was assumed necessary for progress or duty folded to pray, and then resumed hanging sad stories from the branches of my family tree.

Although I haven’t sorted through how my faith and citizenship work together, I know that nationalism and Christianity don’t mix.

I believe Christ offers soul redemption for all people, regardless of where they live or what they’ve done. Accepting that means forsaking all other banners or principalities competing for my loyalty. Because of that, sometimes being a Christian means looking like a bad citizen. It’s unpatriotic.

Pledging allegiance to my God, not to the whims of a person or a country’s governance or popular opinion, doesn’t mean I’m apolitical or apathetic to the concerns of earthly existence. Following Christ means that I question my alliances and hold myself to standards higher than the laws of the country where I reside.

In a way, Jesus did get his hands dirty, but it was by serving the sick, outcast, downtrodden. He got downright messy making a political and spiritual statement by covering himself with his own blood.

Leave a Comment