Skip to content

Taxes & tobacco: Forum addresses ballot questions

Richard Fulton

Thursday night’s candidates forum at the Nodaway County Courthouse didn’t offer much in the way of excitement with regard to the two local contested races — one for sheriff and the other for North District county commissioner.

But thanks to Richard Fulton, a retired Northwest Missouri State University political science professor, it did provide some insight into a number of state initiatives appearing on the Nov. 8 General Election ballot.

Promoted by special interests or addressing thorny political questions, like the state’s tobacco tax and a legislative push for voter photo IDs, this year’s round of ballot initiatives are both confusing and complex.

Fulton, however, tried his best to cut through the tangle by offering concise explanations of most of the issues at hand while mostly avoiding comments reflecting his personal political viewpoint, which in his regular column for the Maryville Daily Forum tends to land left of center.

However, the professor did let some subjectivity show through in his comments on Amendment 3, a cigarette sales tax increase backed by the major tobacco companies.

Fulton described the measure as a “Trojan horse amendment” dangling before voters the prospect of $300 million a year in new revenue for early childhood education while at the same time offering protections to “Big Tobacco.”

For one thing, the amendment punishes smaller tobacco companies, referred to as “non-participating manufacturers,” not included in a multi-billion dollar court settlement levied against cigarette makers for deceptive advertising designed to downplay the health risks of smoking.

If passed, the proposal, which would become part of the Missouri Constitution, will levy a 60-cent tax increase on Big Tobacco products to be phased over the next four years. “Small tobacco,” on the other hand, would face a 67-cent increase above Missouri’s existing 17-cent-per-pack levy, one of the nation’s lowest.

The majority of new revenue from the increase would be spent in the form of grants for early childhood education programs with between 10 and 15 percent of that money to be distributed to hospitals and healthcare facilities for childhood health initiatives.

The remaining 5 to 10 percent would go for smoking prevention programs for pregnant mothers and youth.

Fulton further noted that the amendment would prohibit revenue from being spent on abortion services or clinics, human cloning research, therapies using human embryonic stem cells, and — get this — tobacco-related research linking cigarettes to health risks.

The longtime political scholar also addressed a competing tobacco tax measure, Proposition A, which is backed by both “small tobacco” and the Missouri Petroleum Markets and Convenience Store Association.

If passed, the tax would increase the 17-cent levy on cigarettes by 13 cents in 2017, five cents in 2019, and five cents in 2021. It would also tax non-cigarette tobacco products by 5 percent of the manufacturer’s invoice price paid by the seller.

Revenue from the 23-cent tax increase would be deposited into the Transportation Infrastructure Fund used to repair and maintain Missouri’s roads and bridges.

One interesting sidebar, Fulton said, is that no one really knows what will happen if both Amendment 3 and Proposition A become law. Most likely, he speculated, the question will end up in court.

Turning to other matters besides how much it will cost Missourians to light up, Fulton tackled Amendment 2, a measure meant to place restrictions on campaign spending, which in Missouri are now non-existent.

In fact, Missouri is the only state in the union lacking campaign finance limits, lobbyist gift limits, and a cooling-off period for legislators leaving office and immediately becoming lobbyists.

Amendment 2 would establish caps on campaign contributions to state and judicial candidates of $2,600 from individuals and $25,000 from committees and political parties.

Fulton noted that corporations and labor unions would be prohibited from making direct contributions, although they could still donate through political action committees, known as PACs.

Other proposed restrictions govern gifts from out-of-state committees and corporations, non-citizens, and foreign governments. Only contributions under $25 would remain anonymous, and all limits on campaign contributions would be adjusted every four years relative to inflation.

Additional ballot measures, Fulton said, include Amendment 4, which would forbid the state and local governments from enacting sales and use taxes on any service or activity not already subjected to one on January 1, 2015. He noted that as a constitutional amendment, the measure could not be repealed except by a vote of the people.

Fulton also addressed Amendment 6, which would authorize the Legislature to enact a law requiring voters to present a form of identification to vote.

The measure would trigger existing legislation requiring voters to present valid photo identification at the polls, a move widely criticized by Democrats as an attempt to disenfranchise minority voters living in impoverished urban areas.

The bill, known as House Bill 1631, would allow citizens without a photo ID to vote if they present a school identification, utility bill, bank statement, paycheck, or other government document, permit their picture be taken, and sign a statement.

Fulton said voter photo ID requirements have proved problematic when challenged in federal court, and predicted the Missouri law will “have trouble constitutionally” as well. He also said that there is little or no credible evidence that voter fraud is a significant problem in the United States.

Leave a Comment