Conviction on social media is not in our ‘game plan’

Phil Cobb
In the newspaper business, we tend to do things the way we’ve always done them.
There’s a good reason for that — the old “don’t fix it if it ain’t broke” theory.
But from time to time, circumstances dictate that we adapt our ways.
One way that has become true for the Maryville Daily Forum in recent months is the method in which we handle stories about people who have been arrested and charged with crimes.
About 15 years ago, and before, if someone were arrested and charged with a crime, the newspaper would run the story with a head-and-shoulders photograph of the subject.
Then came the internet, or at least the wider acceptance of the internet, and the advent of the newspaper website.
Naturally, it became commonplace for the story and mug shot to run in the newspaper and on the website.
This was a common practice and widely accepted as standard operating procedure throughout the newspaper industry.
It did, however, increase the number of eyeballs on the subject.
Not only could people who bought the newspaper find out that you were charged with breaking the law, now anyone with an internet connection had access to the same information.
Still not a problem.
Still widely accepted.
The common thinking was that if you didn’t want your mug shot in the newspaper, you shouldn’t commit a crime.
I couldn’t agree more.
Then came social media.
A newspaper uses social media, such as Facebook and Twitter primarily to drive readers to its website.
Contrary to what seems to be popular belief, the newspaper has no obligation to provide information for free on social media.
Essentially, when we post a link to a story, the sole purpose is to promote it to the greatest number of potential readers possible.
I realize that most people don’t know the difference between Facebook and the internet, but we do not put our stories on Facebook.
We post links on Facebook that connect readers to the stories on our website.
So, keeping in line with the progression of things, newspapers industry wide began to post links to all types of stories on Facebook, and more recently, on Twitter.
This dramatically increased the volume of traffic to news sites.
It also allowed people the ability to comment on those stories, whether or not they had a connection to the newspaper, those accused, or in a lot of cases, even the town or the state in which the newspaper is located.
Many times, in my estimation, people don’t even click on the link to get the full story.
They simply see a picture or a name and immediately jump to conclusions.
If you’ve spent any time on Facebook, you know that people can get pretty nasty.
They tend to say things in the comments section that they would never say in person, or even over the phone.
I could be alone in this, but I recently made the decision to discontinue posting links to stories about people who have been charged with — not convicted of mind you, but charged with — breaking the law.
In my opinion, connecting these stories to social media is the modern day equivalent to passing out stones.
And it has become apparent that people enjoy casting stones a little too much for my comfort.
Links to stories of this type have been far and away the most popular on our Facebook page, but no longer will we participate in what has become no better than public shaming.
It’s one thing to post something on the Daily Forum’s own page, but once people share it on their own pages, and beyond, we have no way to control, or even monitor, the results.
Frankly, I’m ashamed to have not made this decision sooner.
We will continue to provide information, as we always have, through traditional means, but no longer will we promote these types of stories on social media.
If that’s the only thing that brings you to our website, then frankly I couldn’t care less if you read it or not.
Again, we have zero obligation to provide this, or any, information on social media.
We want to provide relevant information to our readers, including that of potential threats, but in no way do we want to take part in being judge, jury, or executioner.
