County tries to nose out courthouse smell

TONY BROWN/DAILY FORUM
For months, an unpleasant smell hinting of raw sewage has been a recurring problem inside the Nodaway County Courthouse, the first floor of which is pictured here. Plumbing repairs and smoke testing have failed to eliminate or pinpoint the odor, which North District County Commissioner Robert Westfall said is most noticeable when the temperature hovers between 35 and 40 degrees.
Something stinks at the Nodaway County Courthouse, but the situation has nothing to do with insider politics, cover-ups, or corruption.
Which is to say the inside of the landmark Victorian structure, built in 1881 and listed on the National Register of Historic Places, just plain smells bad sometimes.
The odor, which carries an unmistakable hint of raw sewage, has been an intermittent problem at the courthouse for about two years, according to North District County Commissioner Robert Westfall, who takes the lead on most county issues having to do with facilities and maintenance.
Westfall and his colleagues on the governing board, Presiding Commissioner Bill Walker and South District Commissioner Robert Stiens, acknowledge that the smell makes the courthouse less than a pleasant place to be, and the panel has made a number of attempts to trace the source of the stink and get rid of it.
But so far, no soap.
After the smell first became a problem, the commission called in both Nelson Plumbing of Maryville and IHP, an industrial heating and plumbing contractor in St. Joseph, to find whatever was causing the odor and eliminate it.
Westfall said about 25 feet of old lead-jointed sewer pipe in the courthouse basement was replaced with plastic, and that an aging vent pipe was blocked off in an upstairs bathroom used by jurors.
In addition, the county partnered with the City of Maryville, which had hired Trekk Design Group out of Kansas City to smoke test sewer lines in an attempt to isolate storm water infiltration into the municipal sanitary sewer system.
Two subsequent smoke tests failed to nail down the source of the problem, said Westfall, who added that tracing the smell has been like “looking for a needle in a haystack.”
Westfall noted that the odor seems to be in some way connected to the weather and is most noticeable when the temperature hovers between 35 and 40 degrees.
After the initial repairs were made in the courthouse basement and upstairs bathroom, the odor problem appeared to have been solved, but Circuit Court Clerk Elaine Wilson said it came back especially strong last week — just in time for a jury trial.
She said she and her staff have experienced headaches on days when the smell is most apparent, and that the stink is especially strong on Monday mornings after the courthouse has sat empty over the weekend.
In terms of discomfort, Wilson said the combination of the sewage smell with that of an air freshener used by the maintenance staff to mask it can be a little overwhelming.
Westfall said plumbing and facilities professionals have told him the smell poses no major health risks but is certainly unpleasant.
“It’s just an uncomfortable smell,” he said.
While a solution is proving elusive, Westfall said the commission intends to keep working to find an answer and will likely conduct a third smoke test.
