Skip to content

Being certain we understand what the political polls tell us

Richard Fulton

This week’s election results were quite interesting.

While Donald Trump continues to win primaries, mostly with less than 40 percent of the vote (save for Mississippi), and Bernie Sanders surprises in Wisconsin, the lay of the land remains fundamentally unchanged.

Never mind that the news media play follow the leader and blow with any prevailing wind, the name of the game is still delegate count. And in this arena, Trump remains ahead, but without a majority of the delegates chosen so far, and Clinton remains ahead of Sanders by a two-to-one margin.

So far, the two front-runners have had to split the delegates in most states because they were distributed on a proportional basis. The percentage of votes equals the percentage of delegates. Some states, however, have a winner-take-all distribution.

This is what makes next Tuesday such a crucial point so early in the process; two states with large numbers of delegates give them all to the winner.

Ohio and Florida may well be the tipping point for Trump.

If he wins them and does well in the other large states with primaries Tuesday — states like Illinois, New Jersey, and Missouri, it may be all over for the Republicans.

The same is true for Hillary Clinton. Unless Sanders uses the momentum built from winning the highest number of votes in Michigan (though splitting the delegates virtually in half) to surge in these large states, Clinton will have an almost insurmountable lead in delegates.

Still, if Trump does not win in both the winner-take-all states and keeps under 40 percent in the other states, the opposition could live on to fight in states to come with lots of delegates to win.

And if Bernie Sanders can surge to win either Florida or Ohio, then he becomes a viable alternative to Hillary Clinton.

In all of this, the media swing like bird feeders in the wind. First Sanders has no chance against Clinton. Then he surges and is a viable threat when he wins Michigan.

Trump has the nomination sewed up, until Rubio wins a few states and then he is vulnerable. This last week, then, Trump is a “winner” again.

The media too often ignores the delegate count as the crucial statistic. It’s more fun to talk about who won the state. Did Sanders win Wisconsin; or was it a tie? He won a slim majority of the vote, but virtually equal numbers of delegates.

The worse part of the media is its use of opinion polling.

Sanders “surged” and caught up from 20 points behind in Michigan. What a comeback. Except the polls must be better understood.

The poll that showed Sanders behind by 20 points had a 5 percent error factor. What does that mean? It means that if Clinton was ahead (for simplicity’s sake) 60 percent to 40 percent, the possibilities for the actual support for each varies by 5 percent points plus and minus.

So Clinton’s true support could be 55 percent or 65 percent, or anything in between. And Sander’s support could be 45 percent or 35 percent, or anything in between. Was Clinton ahead by 20 points or 30 points? Was her lead only 10 percent?

Statistically, any of these could be true.

The news media needs to be clearer about the polls. It is even more important when the numbers are closer together. What does it mean if some candidate is ahead by 5 percentage points if the error factor is 4 percent? Or even 3 percent. Nothing.

Most professionals will tell you that any poll worth paying attention to must have a 3 percent or less error factor.

And few have met this standard this election cycle.

Too often, the mass media fail to give the error factor, thus failing in their duty to provide accurate information let alone analysis.

Leave a Comment