One of this country’s major battles has been waged forever

Jim Fall
Last summer while leisurely steaming up the Mississippi River from New Orleans to Memphis aboard the American Queen, I was aware of the history concentrated around New Orleans, Natchez and Vicksburg, Mississippi, and Memphis.
I knew how important the City of New Orleans had been during the War of 1812, and, of course, I knew about Natchez and Vicksburg and the roles they had played in determining the final outcome of the War Between the States.
Having grown up in West Memphis, Arkansas — and having had relatives on my mother’s side of the family who fought for the Confederacy — I obviously also knew about the role Memphis had played.
But I was almost clueless about what is really the biggest battle along the Mississippi River.
I think I can safely say I had “heard” about the centuries-long struggle for control of the river — the “real” control of the river as it continues its quest for the shortest route to the Gulf of Mexico.
That particular “battle” began long before any shoot-outs between the now famous ironclads in the middle of the river in the middle of the 1860s, much less the more modern conflicts over the industrialization and the pollution of Ol Man River as it rolls along between Baton Rouge and the Crescent City.
That particular battle is the struggle to keep the Mississippi River from diverting itself into the Atchafalaya River and on to the Gulf by a shorter, and steeper, route.
Granted, that path would create a lot of havoc for the petrochemical concentration which currently exists between Louisiana’s two most important cities — in today’s world, anyway — and it would probably just wash Morgan City out into the Gulf of Mexico, literally, as it shifted the “mouth” of the Mississippi something more than 100 miles to the west.
That would not be an unheard of result in the course of major rivers throughout history. The Nile, the Tigris, and the Euphrates rivers are the most convenient examples of such dramatic, and inconvenient, relocations throughout the years.
The Mighty Mississippi has already shifted its course at least three times over the centuries.
As long as 3,000 years ago, the main channel shifted hundreds of miles east, and then maybe 800 years before the birth of Christ, it made another dramatic move.
By the second century AD, it had moved again, all the while making more of Louisiana by depositing more silt and sand as it ebbed and flowed along its way.
By the 1950s, the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers was fully committed to preventing another shift in the main channel, a battle it has been fighting, officially, anyway, since 1879 when the Mississippi River Commission was created with the charge to “prevent destructive floods.” It was left to the Corps to determine exactly how to do that.
According to John McFee in the section on Atchafalaya in his book, The Control of Nature, it may be something like Don Quixote doing battle with those infamous windmills.
In the words of Norris Rabalais, one of the main leaders on the Crops’ fight to control nature, “Whenever you try to control the river, you have one strike against you.”
So, with just two swings left, the Corps has jumped, headlong, into the epic struggle to control the mightiest of all American rivers, representing the third largest drainage basin in the world, behind on the Nile and the Congo rivers.
The Mississippi is, after all, the ultimate destination of almost every drainage system from the Rocky Mountains, across the Upper Midwest, and into the Ohio Valley, including the Arkansas and Red rivers in the Southwest.
That amounts to 41 percent of the United States, and two Canadian provinces, a watershed of approximately 1.8 million acres.
And it all comes together near where the Red River empties into the Atchafalaya River, about seven miles west of the present Mississippi River.
Simply stated, the Atchafalaya is not only the shorter route to the Gulf, it is also well below the current elevation of the Mississippi riverbed.
The major decision by the Corps to control the Mississippi has resulted in an extensive system of levees — that dwarf the Great Wall of China in length and height — and floodways, of which the Atchafalaya is the most important, normally carrying as some 30 percent of the actual flow.
The earliest “modern” flood was in 1927, followed by major “situations” in 1937, 1959, 1993, and most recently in 2011.
With that history, according to McPhee, the Corps’ lines of defense are adequate to keep the river in check — for the time being.
And they are positioned to continue to do so — at least until the next 100-year flood, maybe next year, maybe in 20 years, or maybe never.
But, as McPhee quotes a Corps geologist, “If the right circumstances are all put together, there is a very definite possibility the river will divert, go down through the Atchafalaya Basin.”
That has been avoided, so far, sometimes just barely, but as the Washington Post stated editorially:
“Who will win as this slow-motion confrontation between humankind and nature goes on?
“No one really knows. But after watching Mt. St. Helens and listening to the guesses about its (the Mississippi’s) performance, if we had to bet, we would bet on the river.”
The Corps has bet hundreds of millions of dollars agsinst that.
