Skip to content

Prosecutor: Truck trade-out was legal

TONY BROWN/DAILY FORUM
A Nodaway County-owned Caterpillar D250E articulated dump truck was recently used by Loch Sand & Construction of Maryville to perform work at a private apartment complex development along Main Street just south of Wal-Mart. A legal opinion rendered this week by Nodaway County Prosecuting Attorney Robert Rice said Loch’s use of the truck was lawful since the company agreed to provide the county with an equivalent amount of concrete work on a future bridge project.

Nodaway County Prosecuting Attorney Robert Rice this week issued a legal opinion stating that the recent use of a large piece of county-owned earth-moving equipment by a local private contractor working on an apartment complex expansion in Maryville was allowable under both state statutes and the Missouri Constitution.

Members of the Nodaway County Commission said last week that they allowed Loch Sand & Construction to use the Caterpillar articulating dump truck in order to move earth made heavy by rainfall at the site of phase-two construction at Southview Apartments.

When completed, the 32-unit complex, located at 321 Volunteer Avenue just south of Wal-Mart, will consist of two buildings containing 16 apartments each. The project is an addition to an existing 40-unit development, opened in 2013. Both projects are owned by Tennessee-based Volunteer Management & Development Co.

Partially funded through tax credits approved by the Missouri Housing Development Commission, the apartments are tailored to low- and moderate-income families, especially those with children, whose household incomes total between 60 and 80 percent of the area median.

Presiding Commissioner Bill Walker said Friday that the large, six-wheel dump truck was provided to Loch at the local contractor’s request. The deal included a handshake agreement between the county and the contractor, under which, in exchange for using the truck for about 10 days in early November, Loch is to provide the county with concrete work related to future bridge construction.

No money changed hands, Walker said, and the deal was not formalized with any kind of written agreement or contract. In addition, no immediate calculation was made comparing the value of the truck’s use with the as-yet-unspecified concrete work.

However, the number of truck-use hours was recorded, and the three commissioners and Road and Bridge Superintendent Larry Dougan said that information would be used to compute an equivalent trade-off.

Dougan said Tuesday that if the county were to rent such a truck to make road or bridge repairs approved by the Federal Emergency Management Agency, the reimbursement rate through the agency would be $115 an hour.

South District Commissioner Robert Stiens said the meter on the truck showed that Loch operated it at the Southview site for a total of 37 hours.

A citizen complaint about the arrangement made to the Daily Forum led the newspaper to bring the matter to Rice’s attention in order to determine its legality.

In rendering his opinion, Rice cited statutory provisions that appear to allow Missouri counties to trade out equipment with public or private entities for a number of reasons, including the furtherance of projects deemed to have a positive impact on economic development.

“Presently the law allows the commission to engage in activities designed for the purpose of promoting and developing economic growth within the county,” Rice stated. “In addition, the commission may contract with any firm, corporation, association, or person for the purpose of implementing the provisions of this law.”

Rice added, however, that there is a line that cannot be crossed, and that the legal standard in such cases bars counties and other political subdivisions within the state from simply loaning out goods, services, and equipment without equivalent compensation.

“The Missouri Supreme Court has held an appropriation must be in return for goods, services, or other consideration in order to not be in the nature of a gift or grant in violation of the Missouri Constitution,” the prosecutor wrote, explaining that, under law, a gift or grant is defined as simply giving something away for free.

“In this case,” Rice stated, “the Nodaway County Commission did not grant or gift county equipment since the county received in return product or services from Loch. It would have been a gift or grant had Nodaway County not received a return for goods, services, or other consideration.”

Rice also said he failed to find a legal requirement that such agreements between the county and a private company or other agency, private or otherwise, must be made in writing.

“In short,” Rice wrote, “it is my legal opinion that the commission was legally authorized to make such an agreement and did not violate the constitution or state statute, since the commission received valuable consideration in exchange for the use of county equipment.”

South District Commissioner Robert Stiens, who generally takes the lead on road and bridge matters for the county, said last week he did not know when Loch would be asked to provide the agreed-to work, but that the company’s half of the trade-off would involve bridge construction.

Dougan said Tuesday that the decision to let Loch use the truck was made by the commission, and that the first he heard of the arrangement was when he was contacted by Loch project manager Mike Luke near the end of October.

He added that, to his knowledge, this is the first such deal struck between the commission and a private contractor, though the county has made similar trade-offs with several of Nodaway’s 15 townships, political subdivisions charged primarily with graveling roads and maintaining small drainage tubes.

Loch Sand & Construction was working at Southview under Republic-based Woodco Inc., which was hired by Volunteer Management & Development as the project’s general contractor.

Leave a Comment