Skip to content

Shisler House visit turns into snooze time

Last weekend, my fiancée and I traveled to Atchison, Kansas, to investigate the Shisler House.

Now, Atchison has earned the title of “Most Haunted City in Kansas”, so we were ready to walk away with a vast amount of paranormal experiences and evidence.

And the Shisler House in particular is reported to be a hotbed of activity, haunted by members of the Manglesdorf family who originally built and occupied the home.

But that’s not exactly what happened.

First we had to order tickets to be able to tour the house. I have no issues with that; I am ready and willing to pay for awesomeness.

My issue is that when I ordered our tickets I was told that the Shisler House would be open for self-guided tours, we would be able to take our time and explore every inch of the house with our equipment at our own pace without being subjected to annoying tour guides.

I was also given the impression that the Shisler House was not a residence, it was a home maintained by the city for the specific purpose of being open to paranormal tours.

So imagine my surprise when we rolled up to the Shisler House, which does not look anything like it is portrayed on the city of Atchison’s website by the way, and discovered that there was a family living there.

And they were renovating the home, so we were not able to investigate freely, as was promised.

And we were trapped in the living room for 45 minutes by the homeowner who acted as our self-appointed tour guide.

I was throwing so much shade and side-eye I’m surprised my eyes didn’t permanently roll back into my head. I know I saw my brain at least twice.

So, Adam and I resigned ourselves to our 45-minute living room purgatory with another couple from Oklahoma, who looked far more excited to be there than we were at that point, and listened to Beatrice Shisler talk about her paranormal experiences in the home.

For 45 minutes.

Now, while Beatrice seems like a genuinely nice person, a storyteller and public speaker she is not. I’m fairly certain I drifted off.

For a house that is reputed to have some of the most interesting reports of paranormal activity in all of Atchison, nothing really freaking happened.

Seriously, all those reports and all that alleged evidence and only two weird things happened.

I seemed to be sitting in a cold spot during Beatrice’s monologue, because even though I was dressed in boots, jeans, and a sweater I was freezing cold. Goosebumps, cold chills, hair growing on my legs cold. Everyone else was fine. Even Adam, who was quite literally two inches away from me was perfectly comfortable, warm even.

The second thing, I still haven’t been able to explain. The only people in the home at this time were Beatrice, her husband, myself, Adam, and the other couple. Beatrice’s husband was upstairs and the rest of us were congregated in the living room.

During one of my drifting off periods, I let my gaze wandering to the dining room.

Now, the dining room in this house features large picture windows covered in gauzy curtains. I was gazing at these windows thinking about what I wanted to eat afterwards (I decided on nachos for those who are interested) when I saw a man’s forearm and hand, covered in a long blue sleeve, reach out and tweak one of the curtains into a better position, then disappear.

‘Must be the husband,’ I thought, and assuming he had come downstairs at some point, resumed my daydream about nachos.

No sooner had I finished that thought then the husband came thundering down the stairs. Dressed in a white t-shirt. So it wasn’t him. And I did confirm that there was no one else in the home.

So who tweaked the curtain?

I don’t know, and after that torturous “tour” I don’t even think I care.

Given my experience with the Shisler House and Atchison, I advise true paranormal enthusiasts to avoid the Atchison paranormal community like the plague, and travel to Kansas City to visit and investigate some of the historical haunted landmarks there.

In Kansas City you’re not lead astray about the investigation you’ve signed up for, you’re working with true professionals, and you get your money’s worth.

Overall, the Shisler House was a complete bore, and a waste of ticket and gas money.

The most exciting thing to happen on this investigation was that I got carsick on the ride to and from Atchison. And I never got my nachos.

Leave a Comment