Skip to content

Middle-class jobs may lag, but good jobs outstrip bad

Richard Fulton

Good news last week.

The unemployment rate reached 5.1 percent, the lowest rate since the recession started at the end of the Bush administration when the rate was near 10 percent. The longest continuous job growth in U.S. history: 16 million private sector jobs.

The economy continues to improve.

The Gross Domestic Product is expanding at about 2.5 percent. Add this to the fact that the annual federal deficit has declined by two-thirds from what it was in 2009.

The deficit is still something to keep an eye on, but too few give Obama credit for significantly slicing that yearly deficit.

It must be said that the improvement has been slower than we would like, but the improvement is clear and steady. Even the recent worries over the Chinese economy and the still sluggish European economies have not deterred that improvement in the United States.

What is true is that the recovery has been too top-heavy. Corporate and high-end individuals’ incomes have been disproportionately high while salaries of workers has stagnated, on the whole.

The cry, however, is that the jobs being created are mostly low paying, entry level positions that tend to lead nowhere. Though it is true that there are a lot of minimum-pay positions in the American economy and that a rising economy creates more of those jobs.

But we forget that entry level jobs can lead to advancements that still give individuals an opportunity to improve their personal economics, and thus their quality of life.

Still, the critics decry an economy that only creates low paying jobs.

But the critics are too harsh.

USA Today recently reported on a new study by the Georgetown University’s Center for Education and the Workforce that found a different story. They looked at employment, not by industries, but by occupations. The more reported approach has led to over emphasizing low-wage jobs.

The article by Paul Davidson summarizes the 6.6 million jobs added to the economy in the recovery:

“Based on that measure (by industry), nearly three million, or 44 percent, of the jobs added from 2010 to 2014 were high paying positions with salaries above $53,000. Only 1.9 million, or 29 percent, of the newly formed jobs were middle-wage — $32,000 to $53,000 — and 1.8 million, or 27 percent, were low-wage — less than $32,000.”

Given this data, it is clear that many more good jobs are being created than bad ones. This reflects the fact that there is an increasing need for skilled workers who can deal with increased technologies and management needs.

However what happens with many reports of more low-wage jobs created is that they measure industries not occupations.

For example, fast-food places, nursing homes, and other places of low-paid personnel also hire accountants, managers, executives, chefs for nursing homes and restaurants.

They need skilled mechanics for upkeep. In short, there are many medium and high paying positions in these industries.

So you see, by looking at occupations, as does the Georgetown study, a different picture emerges.

I don’t want to denigrate the data that shows that the great middle-class worker has not had pay increases of any note for this same period of time while the rich and the upper management sectors of the economy flourish.

This certainly is a problem.

And we must not forget that corporate and financial interests take a disproportionate piece of the profits of our economy while reinvesting too little of that profit.

We must understand, however, that attacking the administration for not producing quality jobs is just not based upon fact.

Leave a Comment