Skip to content

Jeb Bush seen to be favorite among GOP many candidates

Richard Fulton

Back in April, Nate Cohen, in a New York Times article, looked at the GOP presidential field and divided them into three categories: Invisible Primary Leaders; Mainstream Alternatives, and Fictional Favorites.

Looking at the field after the recent CNN debates, he may not have been far off the mark. His only key problem was that he was writing before the phenomenon of Trump. Still, his main thesis may still play out.

The Invisible Primary Leaders are, of course, not truly invisible, but they remain the shadow favorites to end up with the nominations.

The defining element here is the “loyalty of party elites.” Cohen thinks that only Jeb Bush fits the bill, though weakly. His great lead in money and the lack of any candidate taking the lead helps though.

Most felt that his showing at the debate was pretty lackluster, with no signature issue to energize his campaign. That may come, but he does seem, well, boring.

Does Donald Trump throw a wrench into this logic?

Only so far as he makes it more difficult for other potential “Leaders” to emerge — people like Marco Rubio and Scott Walker. Cohen thought Rick Perry might fit here too, but poll numbers and his performance at the “other” debate seem to knock him out.

The debate did not thrust any of these into an obvious threat to Bush.

The “Mainstream Alternatives” are those “broadly acceptable across the party and qualified to be president.”

They include Walker, Rubio, Jindal, Christie, and Kasich. One of these will probably emerge as the main challenger to Bush.

They seem viable because Rubio and Jindal could rally the right while not being unacceptable to the rest of the party.

Christie and Kasich could rally the moderates and squeak through if the right is seriously split.

And Scott Walker has presented an image of a fighter and champion of responsible fiscal policies. His anti-union stand resinates with many business conservatives in his party.

Marco Rubio made a good impression during the debate and could rally voters, given his youth and forceful rhetoric. Walker not so much his charisma ranking rather low.

Bobby Jindal did not do well in the debates either. He simply made no impression. Christie had some moments when challenging Trump and Rand Paul, but still seemed to lack a direct message.

Many thought that John Kasich, a late comer into the race, did quite well, helped by a home-town crowd. He seems moderate with some positions not in line with the rest. And that is his problem in the long run.

The “Fictional Favorites” are candidates mired in niches with little room to broaden their appeal. Rand Paul is a libertarian at heart, much to the right of the party.

Ted Cruz is a rather blunt Tea Party favorite and Mike Huckabee is a champion of the evangelical wing of the party. Chris Christie is perceived as too moderate by too many in the party and has New Jersey around his neck.

All did not shine in the debates with views that reflected their more narrow potential base of support.

Ben Carson and Carly Fiorina should fit in this last category. Carson came across in the debates as a sort of “everyman” candidate. He does well on the stump and gives a fresh face to the party. He may surprise in the early contests.

Fiorina surprised everyone by dominating impressions from the early debate. But she has little experience, no natural base (unless she excites women in the party), and a shrill reputation. Can’t see the disparate elite of the party warming to her. Both these also lack resources.

So, Jeb Bush? Or one of the Mainstream Alternatives? Or could one of the Fictional candidates take off? At least we should recognize the odds, broadly, for those in each of the three categories.

Leave a Comment