Skip to content

What do we want America to be?

Matt Pearl

My parents, teachers, counselors and others, as I recall, placed great emphasis on my deciding what I wanted to be when I grew up, and their insistence was that I decide such before I had actually become an adult.

I’ve wondered at times lately what America wants to be when it grows up.

When I studied the Civil War in school, I always kind of believe that was when America had become fully grown: we had divided along geographical and ideological lines, but the union had been preserved.

How grown up were we then? After a bloody war where everyone involved was fighting to the death against their own countrymen – a disturbingly violent tale of American bloodshed – Lincoln pardoned every single Confederate, from General to Private. When it was over, it was over.

In 1865, with the exception of the Quantrill-types who wanted to keep the flames fanned and America fighting, the country began to fall back in love with being the unified face of national freedom. Within the next couple of decades, the USA took hold on the Industrial Revolution, and this country became the most powerful on the planet.

Now, we have re-divided along essentially the same geographical lines as before. Ideologically, it’s a similar fight as well. Except instead of slavery, the pawn in the human rights struggle becomes the impoverished minority citizen, or the illegal alien that meets two different nations when he crosses a border: on one side, a country that holds the view that the American dream should be wide open to its would-be citizens; on the other, a nation that has seen the devastation created by outside forces seeking to harm the country.

The interesting part of today’s division is that the country has no means to actually, physically divide. It’s not like 1861, when a state could just declare itself seceded, then have the means to stand on its own militarily for any amount of time.

So instead, we fight in the streets. We antagonize one another in print, or on television news networks who have forgotten their true charge, which is to report the truth of the matter in question.

Half of us make gods of the rich in America, and the other half call them demons – when they are truly neither. There is no balance. The media created the Red State-Blue State model years ago, and now every American feels the need to be a liberal or a conservative.

The danger of this is apparent, and in fact is happening before our eyes.

We choose our news information source based upon personal perspective. We have stopped calling ideas bad, opting instead to label people as bad, the assuming all of their ideas are as rotten as they.

We watch politicians do obviously suspicious things: a would-be presidential candidate hides emails from federal investigators; another candidate from the opposing party seemingly closed down an entire bridge for political gain.

If Ms. Clinton or Gov. Christie were asked to compare himself or herself to the other, I’m sure each would say he or she was nothing like the other. One is a Democrat, after all, and the other a Republican.

But if they both used personal political motivation in deciding to put self before others, all I can see is how much the two remind me of each other.

Leave a Comment