Skip to content

What to look for in a President

LARRY ANDERSON
Larry Anderson

Political scholar Alvin S. Felzenberg offers insight into what to look for in presidential candidates in his recent book The Leaders We Deserved (And a Few We Didn’t). Since the field for election 2016 is uncommonly crowded already, it is good, I think, to consider the following advice to separate the wheat from the chaff. Felzenberg says….

Look for a sense of purpose. The best presidents had specific goals they wanted to achieve in office and worked until they were accomplished. Washington was determined the American experiment in independence and self-government would succeed. Lincoln was committed to ending slavery. Reagan sought economic renewal and the end of the Cold War. All were successful.

How have they met adversity? Overcoming adversity can be transformative. Washington’s tough experiences in the French and Indian War prepared him to command the Continental Army. Lincoln overcame poverty to become a self-educated, self-directed success long before election to the presidency. FDR’s struggle with polio prepared him for the rigors of war and economic depression.

Look for broad life experiences. Felzenberg points out that most great or near great presidents did many things in life and not always successfully. Setbacks can be a teacher. Some presidents had military or work experience that provided discipline and purpose. Coolidge and Truman started at the bottom of the political scale and worked up. Theodore Roosevelt experienced tough physical challenges on the Dakota plains.

Look for a natural curiosity. Curiosity predisposes a candidate to examine the existing world and to be open to new ideas. Lincoln, for example, taught himself military strategy so he could better evaluate the progress of the North’s military effort. He was interested in scientific and technological advancement. Theodore Roosevelt was famous for his investigative capacity and his ability to converse on a wide array of topics. TR wrote many books.

Look for a well-developed sense of integrity. Gerald Ford pardoned Richard Nixon because he felt it was in the nation’s best interests. Washington pardoned Whiskey Rebellion insurgents, and Lincoln found ways to stop the executions of soldiers accused of desertion during the Civil War. These things were done out of conscience and despite political consequence.

Crave humility. Felzenberg points out the best presidents held their egos in check. All knew the people were the boss. All selected the best people available for cabinet positions without regard for rivalry or opposition. Lincoln famously appointed former rivals for his party’s nomination to positions of power because he acknowledged their qualifications.

There are also attributes to avoid in a candidate. These include….

Cynicism and complacency. Politics can cause cynicism, especially among career politicians who begin to think they have seen it all. Bad attitudes can turn into hubris and contempt for the voting public.

Avoid whiners. Felzenberg points out many failed presidents saw themselves as victims. Lyndon Johnson, Richard Nixon and Bill Clinton fall into this category. Focus moves away from the nation to them.

Avoid know-it-alls. These types tend not to listen to the advice of others who may have more specialized expertise than they do. They may appoint “yes men” and “yes women” to speed their own vision. Woodrow Wilson did not seek council. (Lyndon) “Johnson ignored information that ran counter to his impulses and bullied dissenters into submission.”

Steer clear of candidates with a narrow focus. Professional politicians can become disconnected from their constituencies. They may see politics as an end rather than a means. They can become absorbed by details and trivial matters concerning their own political lives.

Stay away from unrelenting ideologues. The reason is simple: ideologues tend to let their ideology supersede the nation’s best interests. Ideology reveals an intellect narrowed by a singular perspective and purpose.

Avoid bearers of grudges. Politics can be a rough game; enemies can be made, but a good president will put them aside when high office has been reached. Andrew Jackson and Richard Nixon used their presidential authority to even things with rivals. Vindictiveness is destructive and distracting.

Pass on those who demonstrate raw assertions of power. “Presidents who confused their personal interests, desires, or policy preferences with the best interests of the country and who pressed to have their way on everything, oblivious to formal and informal constraints inherent in the American political system, inflicted great harm on the nation, the presidency, and themselves.”

There. That may help heading into next year’s election. The difficulty is many of these undesirable features do not manifest themselves until after the votes are counted.

That is why information is so important. That and skills in critical thinking which can lead to clarity of thought and voice.

Larry W. Anderson’s novel, I, Eugenius, is available on Amazon, and at the Maryville Daily Forum

Leave a Comment