Skip to content

Reining in Missouri’s municipal court system

Dan Hegeman

Earlier this year I wrote about bringing an end to the increasingly common practice in many of Missouri’s municipal courts of “taxation through citation.”

This is a system where fines and court fees are used to fund services in municipalities, beyond public safety, and are not established by a vote of the people.

This practice is an abuse of the public trust and the rights of citizens to vote to establish the taxing structure that funds their government.

I am proud to say the General Assembly, in seeking to break this practice of “taxation through citation,” last month delivered Senate Bill 5 to the governor.

SB 5 modifies what’s commonly known as the Mack’s Creek Law — named after a small town in Missouri that in the mid-90’s was found to be collecting almost 90 percent of its revenue solely from traffic fines.

The law currently restricts municipalities to limiting their annual general operating revenue from traffic fines to 30 percent. If signed into law, SB 5 would reduce the 30 percent threshold to 20 percent throughout the state, while St. Louis County and its municipalities would be further restricted to just 12.5 percent.

In addition to updating the Mack’s Creek Law, SB 5 also creates minimum standards that municipal governments must meet.

These minimum standards seek to ensure that municipal governments are operating in a fiscally responsible manner and citizens have access to the laws and regulations created by their municipal government. But, while SB 5 is a good start, other issues have recently come to light that the system of “taxation through citation” extends beyond traffic tickets.

A recent article by the St. Louis Post-Dispatch details some of the ongoing struggles facing residents in some of Missouri’s municipalities.

These residents face ordinance violations and fines for things ranging from overgrown trees, high grass, peeling paint, toys left in the front yard, pants being worn too low to children riding bikes without helmets.

While most ordinances in our municipalities are aimed at health, welfare and public safety, some of these ordinances and the strict application of fines that follow are far beyond what many of us think is reasonable.

Senate Bill 5 was clearly a step in the right direction and a necessary action to protect Missourians from “taxation through citation”. I am glad that the General Assembly was able to find a common sense solution to this problem and I am certain that the increased awareness of these practices from overzealous municipalities will lead to further reforms.

Leave a Comment