Rice won’t file charges in ‘Baby Corbin’ death

TONY BROWN/DAILY FORUM
Nodaway County Prosecuting Attorney Robert Rice, left, talks to reporters Friday while announcing that criminal negligence charges will not be filed in the accidental shooting death of Corbin Andrew Wiederholt.
Nodaway County Prosecuting Attorney Robert Rice announced Friday following a second meeting of the Child Fatality Review Board the he would not file criminal charges in the accidental shooting death Jan. 19 of 9-month-old Corbin Andrew Wiederholt in Elmo.
The board last looked into the case on Jan. 21 and recommended at that time that no charges be filed. However, the final decision remained with Rice who has continued going over the evidence and witness reports in the weeks since the tragedy occurred.
Corbin suffered a head wound shortly before 9 a.m. in the Elmo home of his grandfather, Bill Porter, after the infant’s 5-year-old brother found a loaded .22-caliber Magnum revolver in a bedroom where the baby had been placed in a playpen.
Sheriff Darren White said the boys’ mother, Alexis Wiederholt, was at the house with all four of her children doing laundry. Porter was not at home at the time of the accident.
Corbin was taken by helicopter to Children’s Mercy Hospital in Kansas City, where he was pronounced dead at 11:55 a.m.
The review board, which is required to meet within 48 hours after such fatalities, consists of Rice, Maryville Public Safety Director Keith Wood, Sheriff Darren White, County Coroner Vince Shelby and representatives from the County Health Department and Missouri State Highway Patrol.
Rice told reporters Friday that the brother apparently found the gun inside a cabinet or drawer built into a bed’s wooden headboard. He said Porter stated later that he believed all of his firearms were locked inside a gun cabinet in the home, and that he had forgotten about the revolver stored in the bedroom.
According to Rice, the gun was not in plain sight, and Corbin’s mother, Alexis, was unaware the residence contained an unsecured weapon.
Given those two facts, the prosecutor said, the 5-year-old’s access to the pistol did not rise “to the level of criminal negligence” on the part of either adult.
“The mother was visiting someone else’s home and was not aware that there was a loaded handgun accessible to children,” Rice said.
Under Missouri law, criminal negligence occurs when someone “fails to be aware of a substantial and unjustifiable risk that circumstances exist or a result will follow, and such failure constitutes a gross deviation from the standard of care which a reasonable person would exercise in the situation.”
Rice concluded his remarks by asking people to “pray for the family,” whom he said remain grief-stricken in the wake of Corbin’s death.
He also issued a plea for gun owners to take steps to secure their firearms and keep them out of the hands of children.
“If you have guns in the home, please use gunlocks, and keep your guns locked in a gun cabinet,” Rice said.
With Friday’s decision, Rice said his investigation into the circumstances surrounding Corbin’s death has officially come to a close.
