Skip to content

The House Speaker’s guest should not have been invited

Richard Fulton

The Congress has been sworn in and begun working.

The President has given his State of the Union address and begun trying to build the political base to opt for his proposals.

But already, skulduggery is afoot.

The Constitution clearly gives the legislative powers and the power of the purse to Congress, and rightly so.

A check on that power is the presidential veto.

Likewise, the Constitution has given to the President all executive powers.

These powers include being commander-in-chief of the armed forces and having control of the exercise of foreign policy. He alone “shall receive Ambassadors and other public Ministers” the Constitution says.

And this is the subject I would like to address.

House Speaker John Boehner has invited a foreign “minister” to speak before the House without checking with the State Department or the President.

This clearly is a breach of protocol, if not a thumb in the face of the Constitution.

Other foreign ministers and heads of state have spoken before Congress, to be sure. All have been invited to do so by Congress with the approval of the President to speak on broad topics of the day.

It is a courtesy, basically, given to our allies for some special reason.

By inviting Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu to speak to the House in March on a single subject before Congress, without even informing the President or State Department, Boehner has crossed the line.

Besides the constitutional question, there are other considerations related to this invitation. First of all, Netanyahu’s Likud political party is facing an election wherein he is being pressured from the left and the right over his premiership. The election is less than three weeks from the date of his invited speech.

This comes dangerously close to interference in the elections in Israel. It signals that the U.S favors Netanyahu and his party in that election. Public favoritism in the election process of another nation is firmly against American policy.

This is why Boehner did not check with the President or State Department.

They would have been against such blatant favoritism at election time.

Further, Boehner has invited Netanyahu to speak on a matter before Congress, the bill to levy more sanctions now on Iran. The President has said this would harm the negotiations with Iran and betray our allies in the negotiations.

Note, this is a crass attempt to have Netanyahu influence the policy making of the Congress, and thus, of the United States.

If he is to use the platform of the House to influence a specific piece of legislation, this makes him a foreign lobbyist and law says he must register with the United States as such a lobbyist.

Why this invitation?

Many speculate that this is politically motivated to pressure the President through this public lobbying by Netanyahu (and to put pressure on members of Congress with influential pro-Israeli Jewish constituents and contributors to campaigns).

Indeed, others have speculated that the origin of the idea came from Sheldon Adelson, a billionaire contributor to Republicans and friend of Netanyahu. He gave millions — some say up to $100 million — to Republicans to defeat Obama in 2012.

Perhaps you can buy influence that spits at the Constitution, gives the impression that the U.S. supports one side in a foreign election, and brings a foreign prime minister into Congress to directly influence a single piece of legislation.

Is this what we are coming to?

Leave a Comment