Skip to content

Controlling the political narrative

LARRY ANDERSON
Larry Anderson

In totalitarian countries like Cuba, the political narrative is controlled by the government through force and is, therefore, narrowed to one acceptable practice. In a democracy the narrative isn’t controlled; it is debated with each side hoping to gain enough support through persuasion. Sometimes the methodology involved is honest but often it is not.

In modern America, the debate isn’t defined so much by political party, Democratic or Republican, but by liberal or conservative, Left or Right. Each side has its avenues of presentation, and it is reasonable, I think, to state this country is constantly in a state of politicking, continuing even after an election season has passed. That is healthy, not calamitous.

Here, politics is an ebb-and-flow process. Sometimes one side dominates temporarily, at other times the other. This can be annoying because of the toll sharing takes on partisanship, but it is useful to keep in mind this is democracy at work, a successful course, not the failure it sometimes seems to be. This allows for jerky but steady progress.

Danger in this democracy will only occur when one side seeks to control the narrative without the legitimacy of impassioned discourse. Declaring an argument over is one sign of this; stating “We’re on the right side of history,” may hint of another.

Seeking to narrow the opportunity to present a point-of-view through the establishment of overbearing law is certainly an example of moving away the freedom of expression and toward a singularly correct way of thinking/governing. Look for that. It is becoming uncomfortably common in this nation long-protected in its right to dissent.

The political narrative in America is influenced by a variety of sources. The most obvious is the direct output of politicians declaring position, but we are also heavily influenced by pervasive media which has become more partisan than ever in our divisive climate. The Left controls Big Media, television networks and many large, influential newspapers; the Right counters with talk radio, successful cable programs, and a battery of publications.

Popular culture plays an important role too in the political narrative as does education long determined to change critical thinking as a skillful exercise in judgment, analysis, and pragmatism to that which is sociologically correct.

Danger lies there.

There are several means through which the political narrative is advanced. One is procedural: 1) Identify a crisis; 2) Inflate, exploit, and define the crisis, and; 3) Offer oneself as a solution to the crisis. In other words, what could have been minor is elevated to critical standing by deliberate politicking, the failure to take action, and the exploitation of the indifferent and the uninformed.

There are several examples of this presently occurring. One is the Left’s absurd “War on Women” screed which seems to be floundering in light of the truth. Another–far more serious–is the border situation that could have been handled years ago by determined effort, but was, instead, allowed to fester into an exploitative catastrophe.

Enter Barack Obama, who, after six years of doing nothing, declares a security issue a humane problem and presents himself as an answer to a dilemma he helped create for political purposes.

No real solution to the millions invading this country has been provided. Failure is obvious. Calamity is probable. Everyone is to blame except those most at fault, also part of the narrative.

Political correctness is a means of controlling the narrative. If one is attacked for saying the wrong thing, then intimidation is the method and fear is the result. Soon only the “right” words can spill from one’s tongue. The fact this practice trashes freedom, encourages intolerance, and ruins lives matters not to proponents.

Certainly offering a scapegoat is a long-endured contributor to the political narrative. It is easy to direct displeasure away from one’s actions by pointing out the horrors of another’s. Today’s scapegoat is the white male guilty of the ancient practices of colonialism, slavery, segregation, sexism, and the hoarding of wealth and success. The fact these practices are either long gone or done just as skillfully by all races matters not.

The narrative can be controlled by the content of textbooks, by the volumes struck from the shelves of libraries, by the babbling of social media, and by the shear determination of the indoctrinated and self-absorbed.

That is why the narrative has changed regarding illicit drugs. For generations all were taught drugs were destructive; now they are not in a growing number of states where the thinking has evolved and the tolerance for folly broadened.

Soon the argument will arrive here, and the narrative will be ours with which to deal.

Larry W. Anderson believes national interest has collapsed into self-interest.

Leave a Comment