Skip to content

Pipeline dreams

Richard Fulton

As I write this week’s missive the president is preparing to address the nation on the immigration policies of the nation. I assume by now that the sky is falling, that the president is a dictator and that our economy will explode because of the executive orders of the president.

Keep in mind, if you will, that whatever the president does can simply be reversed or revised by the Congress acting on comprehensive immigration reform. The Senate has sent to the Republican controlled House such a bill. The Republicans refuse to even bring it to a vote. Who then is to blame for inaction on the issue?

The other issue that the president is getting flack over is the Keystone Pipeline. Let me try to bring some perspective to this issue.

First of all, the people of Nebraska (not a haven of Obama support) have asked to slow the process if not stop it. They greatly fear anything that might endanger the underground water supply so vital to the farmers of that and surrounding states. Look to California if you think that resource is not a vital one.

Proponents of the pipeline argue that the oil is needed to help limit imports of oil to the United States. But much of the oil from the pipeline is targeted for export. Not only that America is right now exporting oil. If we need oil so badly why are we exporting it?

Proponents especially expound upon the jobs created by the pipeline. And for two years there would be an uptick in job creation. This, of course, is true. But once completed the pipeline would sustain 50 jobs. Long term this is not a “job creator” project.

Let’s say that the temporary jobs still are important to the economic strength of the nation. How much do they really add to that strength? Let’s keep perspective on the impact of the pipeline.

If we accept, as supporters claim, that the pipeline will create 2,000 construction jobs and perhaps 13,000 jobs for goods and services over two years. In relation to the total job creation in the United States this is a drop in the bucket—and temporary.

The economy has created 8,000 jobs a day—note that is each day—throughout 2014. That means that the 2,000 jobs created by the pipeline is the equivalent of the amount of jobs created in the U.S. every six and a half hours.

The 50 permanent jobs equal the amount created in the U.S. every 10 minutes and 9 seconds. The economy is creating 42,000 jobs each week for each of 2014’s first 46 weeks.

So the impact of the Keystone Pipeline will hardly be a tick in the economy’s jobs creation.

Contrast that with the fact that the shale oil from Canada is significantly dirtier than U.S. sources. Given that 97% of climate scientists believe global warming is a serious threat to the world’s future, why bring this dirty oil to the U.S.?

Given the limited impact of the pipeline on the U.S. economy, why are Republicans so wild about it? Could the fact that the Koch brothers own 1.1 million acres of the shale oil lands in Canada have anything to do with it? That’s the size of Delaware.

This may well be a harbinger of the future. Issues supported by the hundreds of millions of dollars poured into Republican coffers by the Koch brothers and other billionaires may well dominate the agenda of the next Congress.

Leave a Comment