Amendment 3 is bad for schools
I’ll take a moment to be crystal clear on something that I have noted in earlier writings, but believe to be important enough to mention one last time:
Amendment 3 is bad for schools, and I will not be voting in favor of the measure.
It’s the product of folks having their hearts in the right place, but their heads somewhere else. The measure is intended to address the problems that naturally accompany teacher tenure, testing practices and evaluation of personnel in our public schools.
But the provisions of the amendment provide little redress for the true problems facing Missouri schools.
Those problems include issues with all of the above: tenure, evaluation of teachers and testing itself.
The fix to these, however, is not to put into place arbitrary policies intended to crack down on bad teachers by making life unbearable for the rest.
There are employees who abuse tenure, and employers who allow them to do so because of personal neglect of the evaluation systems for teachers that are already in place.
As for testing, I really can’t believe Americans (or at least Missourians) have not already orchestrated the backlash to student testing practices. I’m a teacher, and I believe in testing—but I’m also a human, and I know that there’s a limit to what we can find out about a kid and his educational environment by looking at test data alone.
I haven’t met an administrator yet who believes Amendment 3 is the fix, and I doubt I run into any advocates for the directive between now and voting time. Your choice must be your own, but I believe the proposed amendment would do more to hinder public education than to help it.
The amendment does, however, provide us a particularly obvious example of the philosophies that we are allowing our leaders to use in dictating public policy these days.
We have polarized responses to any and all problems, for one thing. The only fix for education, according to Teach Great, the Amendment 3 advocates, is to throw out tenure, evaluation and testing as we know them and start over.
In America, we have the ultra-Right trying to throw out just about everything this side of the Constitution in an attempt to save this country.
We also have the looney Left progressives working to advance a scary social reform agenda, which harkens to the bureaucratic solutions I hear for just about every problem we face in this state and in this nation.
But here’s a thought: What if we look back at history instead of forward to an uncertain future for some answers?
What if America’s education system were to look back on what has worked the best, and then just do that, instead of putting our faith in policies like Amendment 3, which promise the moon—at a price we can’t afford in the first place?
Testing is fine. Tenure is fine. Evaluating teacher effectiveness is fine. Each has proven to be a valuable tool in helping our schools to perform the best they can. Each is beneficial if used correctly, and each is dangerous when abused.
Sounds like just about anything in this old world, doesn’t it? It makes me wonder if people and their imperfections aren’t somehow to blame for it all.
Matt Pearl is the publisher of the Tri-County News in King City and teaches in the R-1 school district.
