Bluejays walk off against North Nodaway

DALTON VITT/DAILY FORUM
Northeast Nodaway junior pitcher Dallis Coffelt takes a swing at a pitch from North Nodaway junior Breann O’Riley Monday night. The Bluejays won, 8-7, on a walkoff run from senior catcher Bailey Judd.
With tears welling in her eyes Monday night, Northeast Nodaway head softball coach Darlene Conover spoke about the lone senior on her roster.
Minutes before the thought of Bailey Judd playing her final home game opened the tear ducts, the senior catcher darted to the plate to score a walkoff run against North Nodaway in Ravenwood.
With one out and the Bluejays trailing by one run in the bottom of the seventh, junior third baseman Talina Nelson stood on third while Judd stood at second thanks to two errors from the Mustang outfield on fly balls. Northeast Nodaway’s junior pitcher Dallis Coffelt stepped to the plate and pounded a ground ball to North Nodaway sophomore second baseman Bethany Herndon, who flipped the ball to first for the second out of the inning.
As Herndon made the short toss to sophomore first baseman Madison Thompson, Nelson broke for the plate. Thompson threw home, but the throw was wild, allowing Nelson to score easily. Once the ball sailed into the chain link backstop, Judd saw the opportunity to end her final home game with an 8-7 win and made a break for it.
“It was good for her,” Conover said while fighting her emotions. “She’s a girl that plays her heart out and loves softball. It was a good ending for her on our home field.
“(That play) is part of knowing the game.”
Errors from freshman center fielder Bailey Tate and senior right fielder Kammi Frueh allowed Nelson and Judd to reach after they misjudged fly balls. Defense has been a question mark for the Mustangs for a large part of the year, but they played exceptional through the first several innings before miscues began piling up in the later frames.
Although Northeast Nodaway ended up with the victory, it was North Nodaway that grabbed an early advantage with a three-run first inning. The big blow came on a two-RBI single from Thompson, who advanced to second when the ball bounded past Bluejay junior left fielder Jill Spire. Just one batter later, Thompson scored on a base hit from sophomore catcher Kelsi Oberhauser.
Thompson finished the day 2-for-4 with three RBI, two runs scored and a stolen base.
“She’s really, I think, built her confidence,” Mustang head coach Justin Eiken said. “She’s been one of our consistent hitters as far as confidence-wise. She just swings the bat hard. She’s going up there every time expecting to get a hit … She’s really a great hitter and she came through tonight.”
Following a pair of scoreless frames, Northeast Nodaway got on the board in the bottom of the fourth on an RBI single from Judd, scoring Nelson.
However, the Mustangs responded with two more runs in the top of the fifth to extend their lead to 5-1.
The Bluejay rally began in the next half-inning with freshman shortstop Taylor Coffelt and Nelson singling before Judd smacked a ground ball to North Nodaway freshman shortstop Alisha Davison, who’s errant throw allowed both runs to score. In the sixth, Northeast Nodaway tallied three more runs from junior second baseman Allie Runde, junior center fielder Mikeala McCoy and Spire to take a 6-5 lead heading into the final inning.
“It was a big roller coaster because the girls stayed down so long,” Conover said. “They made a mistake and they stayed down, but when we got some hits, that kind of carried through and we never quit.”
With three outs left, the Mustangs again responded with another pair of runs to swing the lead back to their side at 8-7. Junior pitcher Breann O’Riley singled and stole second before Thompson brought her in with a base hit. After Thompson stole a base and advanced to third on a wild pitch, Oberhauser smacked a ground ball back to Dallis Coffelt on the mound. Once the Northeast Nodaway pitcher fired to first base for the out, Thompson took off for home, just beating a throw to give the Mustangs their one-run lead.
“It definitely was a little bit of instinct,” Eiken said of Thompson’s scoring play. “I told her to make sure it gets past the pitcher, anything on the right side, you’re going. She got out there and she saw that the pitcher looked at her, but she was kind of in, ‘oh crap’ mode. She had her mind made up, she was wanting to get across the plate … No fear.”
Naturally, the wild ride wasn’t over yet, as Judd scampered home for her final play at home in a Bluejay uniform. She finished 1-for-4 while also reaching base on three Mustang errors.
Dallis Coffelt finished with 10 strikeouts while allowing two walks and hitting a batter. On North Nodaway’s side, O’Riley struck out six while walking one.
North Nodaway (4-10) has one regular season game remaining at 5 p.m. Tuesday in Hopkins against Stewartsville before facing South Nodaway at 5:30 p.m. Wednesday at Jefferson for the Class 1, District 16 Tournament.
The Bluejays have Tuesday off before playing North Andrew at 7:15 p.m. Wednesday at Jefferson in the same district bracket as the Mustangs. Northeast Nodaway finished the regular season at 3-12.

DALTON VITT/DAILY FORUM
In the second inning of North Nodaway’s 8-7 loss to Northeast Nodaway, freshman center fielder Bailey Tate reaches out for a fly ball.

DALTON VITT/DAILY FORUM
North Nodaway junior first baseman Madison Thompson takes a swing at a pitch from Northeast Nodaway junior pitcher Dallis Coffelt Monday night. Thompson finished 2-for-4 with three RBI, two runs scored and a stolen base.

