Appeal filed in Rouch case
Nodaway County Prosecutor Robert Rice has appealed a ruling by Presiding Circuit Judge Roger Prokes that evidence in a felony drug case against former Northwest Missouri State University communications Professor Matt Rouch must be suppressed because it was gathered under the authority of an improperly obtained search warrant.
“Judge Prokes sustained the defendant’s motion to quash the state’s search warrants and suppressed all evidence collected in Matt Rouch’s residence,” Rice said in a written statement Thursday. “The effect of the ruling would be a dismissal of the charges because I would not have evidence to present to a jury.
“I have already filed an appeal with the Western District (of the Missouri Court of Appeals) asking them to review and reverse Judge Prokes’ decision.”
Rice said he now has 15 days in which to file a record of appeal, which will include transcripts of the suppression hearing, and an additional 30 days to file a brief stating why he feels the trial court erred.
Rouch’s lawyer, Robert Sundell, will then have 20 days to file a defense brief, to which Rice is allowed to respond in writing. If the appeals court accepts the case, it will then set a date for oral arguments by both attorneys.
Rouch was arrested last September on charges of cultivating marijuana in his home. His incarceration followed an investigation by university police into remarks Rouch posted on Facebook and made in person to a colleague that could be construed as threatening.
Authorities later concluded both sets of remarks were intended as cynically humorous, but not before Northwest Police Chief Clarence Green had obtained a search warrant for Rouch’s Maryville home.
That subsequent search allegedly uncovered what Green described as a large “marijuana grow” consisting of lamps, plant food, approximately ten live marijuana plants, bags of dried marijuana, and “multiple” bongs and pipes.
Earlier this month, however, Prokes ruled the search invalid, and stated that the seized pot and alleged drug paraphernalia could not be used as evidence in court.
While “law enforcement’s concern in this case is understandable,” Prokes wrote, “the court finds no statutory or case law precedent that authorizes issuance of a search warrant based upon anything less than probable cause that contraband or evidence of a crime would be found.”
On Sept. 6, 2013, according to court documents, Green swore out an affidavit in support of a warrant to seek “a rifle with a scope, a Gatling gun, or other firearms capable of lethal use.” But by that time, Prokes wrote, officers knew Rouch’s Facebook comments regarding the weapons was “most likely hyperbole.”
Prokes also stated that the warrant application made no reference to the context in which the defendant’s statements were made, and “failed to inform the issuing court of the fact that they knew the comments were most likely made in jest.”
The comments in question were apparently banter with regard to the start of a new school year.
“But yes, that’s the beginning of the semester. I’m always optimistic,” Rouch wrote in his Facebook post. “By October, I’ll be wanting to get up to the top of the bell tower with a high powered rifle — with a good scope, and probably a Gatling gun as well.”
When those words were unearthed by a student reporter for “The Northwest Missourian” campus newspaper, university administrators threatened Rouch with punitive action.
“The university has strict policies against, and will not tolerate, threats or incidents of violence,” then-Provost Dunham wrote in a terse message to students, faculty and staff in which Rouch was not mentioned by name. “Northwest will take all appropriate actions that are commensurate with the evidence.”
Rouch wasn’t arrested or charged, however, until a couple of days later, Sept. 5, 2013, when he reportedly told a colleague that he had a bomb in his briefcase. The remark was later revealed to be a reference to the flap over his Facebook post.
Nevertheless, the professor was removed from campus and placed under arrest. He was later released on $25,000 bond.
In order to overturn Prokes’ ruling, Rice will have to prove that the search warrant was issued because authorities had good reason to believe, on the strength of Rouch’s comments, that a crime had been committed or was about to be.
The judge, however, left little doubt that about his belief that Green and other officers overreached.
“The court certainly does not condone the defendant’s politically incorrect statements,” Prokes wrote. “Officials had every right to be concerned and further investigate the defendant. Nonetheless the defendant’s comment was not criminal and was obviously an ill attempt at humor. It is apparent that law enforcement sought and obtained a search warrant as part of their threat assessment protocol and to relieve any lingering concerns about the defendant and his state of mind. However, this rationale for a search warrant is not supported by either state or federal law …”
