Skip to content

A more perfect union

LARRY ANDERSON
Larry Anderson

I recently heard something that stayed with me.

I didn’t know what to do with it immediately, but I’ve had some time since to process the remark.

The commentator said, “Unions built the middle class in the United States of America.”

The speaker’s words implied labor unions managed the construction of the middle class by themselves. That is profoundly false.

The single most important factor in America’s developing middle class since World War II is the expansion of the role of women in the work place. American households went from essentially one income to two. The additional earnings stabilized family economics and expanded possibilities in areas such as education for children, savings, and more and nicer things. This did much to establish the consumer nation we enjoy.

Of the tens of millions of jobs created during that era, some were union. Most were not.

The modern middle class was also born out of entrepreneurship. America is (was?) the most entrepreneurial nation on Earth. Entrepreneurship develops in a free and open market, not in the vacuum of controlled labor that emphasizes protection over creation.

New industries start small, adding workers as the product’s market expands. A labor union, if added, always follows the growth and market success of a company invariably started by one person or a small group, not by a union already in place.

Unions do not create jobs, and, sometimes can even destroy them as in the recent case of union recalcitrance that produced the temporary demise of our beloved Twinkies. The new owners of the Hostess brand are non-union for a reason.

Remember, dual household income, entrepreneurship, manufacturing, and small business created the middle class.

I am not opposed to labor unions in principle. Historically, workers have needed protection from exploitation in the workplace from owners, bosses, and managers. Unions did a lot to bring about reasonable pay, sensible hours, and safe work environments. Credit should go where credit is due.

I am opposed to modern unions in practice. Union efforts to dictate workers’ rights at the polls have been an unfortunate part of labor history. Strikes aren’t common these days, but they tend to be disruptive and a threat to the employer who usually has a clearer picture of a company’s economic health than a union rep out to get all he can grab.

I’ve seen too many companies damaged by unionists, and many union practices simply aren’t democratic. They tend to be socialist, born within a socialistic time, and if not limited can get out of control.

I suggest you read about Wisconsin a couple of years ago before Governor Scott Walker stepped in to save the state’s economy from unions and special interests.

I have had some experience with unions, none that I found to be especially rewarding. Fresh out of high school in 1969, I pounded the sidewalks of St. Joseph in search of work. I finally walked into a small factory and was hired immediately. “You’ll have to join the union in 30 days,” I was told. My hackles went up, but I needed a job and kept my big mouth shut. In 30 days, I joined; dues, I think, were $35.00, a slice out of my paycheck for nothing. I was earning around a $1.75 per hour.

Once my dues were paid, union members made certain I was involved. I was taken to a Sheet Metal Workers meeting where members debated how to wrangle more pay out of management. It was interesting, but I wondered how such a small business could afford their demands.

At the end of that summer, I left the company to go to NWMSU. Next spring, I returned expecting to get my old job back, as promised. The little factory was closed. No company, no job, no workers, no union. Nothing.

One summer during college, I was hired at a unionized plant in Trenton where I was labeled a scab by hardnosed union members. Some unionists wouldn’t lend a hand to a non-union temp. I witnessed a wildcat strike when union members walked off the line in support of a fired employee who wasn’t performing. The slacker got his job back. I didn’t like what I saw then, and still don’t.

Missouri’s recent support of Right to Work was the correct thing to do. No one should have to join a union against his/her will or interests.

Be aware the Left is doing what it can to revive labor unions. Unions traditionally have been owned by the liberal establishment and would be again.

Larry W. Anderson believes in a worker’s right to choose.

Leave a Comment