Holtman sisters bond on, off athletic stages

JASON LAWRENCE/DAILY FORUM
Mollie and Cassie Holtman have hit the links, court and pitch together this year and have experienced success in each sport. The sisters were the only two Maryville golfers to advance to state and they each led the basketball team in a pair of statistical categories. But their favorite sport, soccer, they have the highest expectations for as Cassie just set the single-season assist record and Mollie has 41 goals on the season.
Cassie and Mollie Holtman started playing sports at a young age and have grown into more than sisters through their shared athletic accomplishments.
“Really, we’ve grown together as a duo team rather than as individuals,” Cassie said.
Cassie has pictures of herself as a 4-year-old out playing soccer and that may very well be what got the ball rolling on the Holtman sisters playing three varsity sports together at Maryville High School this year.
While they shared the athletic fields at times last year when Mollie was a freshman and Cassie a junior, this year they have spent nearly every practice of the year together, going from golf to basketball to, the sport they said in unison is their undisputed favorite — soccer.
“I’ve really enjoyed being around her,” Cassie said of Mollie. “She’s grown to be more of a friend than a sister. There’s always just the sisterly feeling and sometimes we have those sisterly quarrels, but I found that she’s just been more of a friend to me and I’ve enjoyed being around her and sharing experiences like golf state.”
“She did become more of a friend,” Mollie said. “She’s one of my best friends because she’s still my sister so I tell her everything. We work well together. We have chemistry on the field and on the court. We really know how to build each other back up.”
But it dates back much further than their days together in the halls of Maryville High School — it goes back to St. Gregory’s School where they were first pushed toward sports.
“I think St. Gregory’s is really where we get our sports and pushed to be in sports and do well in our sports,” Cassie said. “St. Gregory’s really taught us to work hard at everything we did. That’s kind of why we do the three sports together because we know that it’s something we’ve always done.”
It’s also a bit of a case of little sister wanting to be like her older sister.
“I just kind of followed in her footsteps,” Mollie said. “I saw her doing things like golf and that she really enjoyed it, so I was like ‘I want to do that.’ I didn’t enjoy volleyball as much, so freshman year I worked on golf. Then soccer has always been a part of our lives. We started from AYSO as 4-year-olds and just kept doing it.”
Maryville golf coach Brenda Ricks also sees a bit of a family rivalry between the two, as is the case with most siblings.
“Cassie doesn’t like being beat by her little sister and I have to think Mollie gets some satisfaction out of beating her big sister,” Ricks said. “It is kind of interesting to watch the dynamics play out with these sisters.”
Playing soccer and basketball date back to their childhood, while golf was “the luck of the draw,” Cassie said.
“I think golf was honestly the luck of the draw because I started off the summer of my freshman year doing volleyball camps and working with the volleyball team then Brenda (Ricks) started talking to me,” Cassie said. “I went to the camp and I really liked it, so I just kind of picked that up. It’s not something that I’ve always done, but something that I just kind of enjoyed as a hobby. Golf has really grown on me.”
There were also some tough times growing up with sports — times that Cassie said made them love soccer even more.
“There were some rough times I think both of us went through. Twisters, we were like ‘We hate it, we want to quit,’” Cassie said. “But I think it was those times that made us grow to love it more because we learned that even though you have a bad game or a bad season, you have to think about the good games and the good times and how important it’s been in your life and it helps you to push on and make yourself better.”
Maryville soccer coach Dale Reuter, who also coached them with the Twisters, said the girls have a strong work ethic, which has helped them keep improving regardless of which sport it’s in.
“You don’t reach the success they’ve had whether it’s on the basketball court, the golf course or out here on the soccer field without giving up some weekends and missing some parties and not following the mainstream of, ‘I’ll do that tomorrow,’” Reuter said. “They’ve got a good work ethic. They go above and beyond to do what they have to do to be successful.
“They really have that team spirit and that work ethic that they bring to every practice, to every game. They’re not gonna quit. They always give me a frown when I take them off the field. They may understand it, but they just don’t like it. As soon as they’re on the bench for 30 seconds, they’re like ‘I’m ready to go.’ You’ve gotta like that. As a coach, it doesn’t get any better than that.”
Mollie, who scored 41 goals this season, still feels pressure to live up to the lofty accomplishments of her sister, who recently set the single-season assists record at 21 and is a three-time all-conference and district performer to go along with two all-region selections and a first team all-state honor last year on the soccer field.
“There’s definitely a lot of pressure because she’s first team all-state and first team all-conference and all that stuff and I’d like to get there sometime, but I think following in her footsteps,” Mollie said. “I just want to get up there with her and improve as much as she has and maybe play college ball some day.”
Now that Maryville’s season is over, Cassie will start preparing for the next level after signing to play college soccer for Northwest. Both sisters have high expectations for what she can do at the next level.
“Since she’s my sister, I expect a lot of her because I know her abilities and I know she’s a really great player,,” Mollie said. “I’ll really be looking forward to watching her and seeing her play with better players and seeing how much she grows in her college years.”
And Cassie said it was a good fit because she’s still able to watch her younger sisters compete in sports, and her older brother, Chris, who also attends Northwest participate in musicals and other things he’s involved in at Northwest.
“Cassie is the older sister and with that, she brings the leadership. Mollie is patiently waiting for her turn and I think probably packing Cassie’s stuff up and getting her out of the house,” Reuter said. “Mollie understands she is a sophomore even though she doesn’t play like one. She understands that there is a little bit of a hierarchy. Cassie is definitely the rock and Mollie is working toward that.”
One day, Mollie hopes to follow Cassie’s footsteps onto the next level, maybe even to Northwest.
“Hopefully one day, I’d like to play with her again and see how much we’ve both improved within the two years that we don’t get to play together,” Mollie said.
And Cassie is looking forward to watching Mollie work with their younger sister, Maddie, when she gets to high school next year to keep the sister act going.
“I just hope Mollie takes what we’ve done together and brings it together with Maddie when she gets here and build her up and be a support system like me and Mollie have the last couple years,” Cassie said. “I hope she can do the same for Maddie and make her as good of an athlete as she is and Maddie has the potential to be.”
