Skip to content

Council rejects short-term rental, RV park apps

City of Maryville logo

MARYVILLE, Mo. — The Maryville City Council on Monday rejected a special use permit for a short-term rental after neighborhood opposition, and another for an industrial site owner that was looking to set up an RV park aimed at data center construction workers.

During the council’s regular meeting on Monday, council members unanimously rejected the two permit applications.

Short-term rental

The short-term rental permit request came from Jeremy and Julie Simmerman, who purchased the property at 730 Prather Ave. with the intention of continuing to use it as a short-term rental. The property had already been operated as a short-term rental since November 2021 by its previous owner, Walter Brothers Properties. A special use permit is not transferrable and so a new owner must reapply.

Short-term rentals such as Airbnbs allow guests to stay for short periods, typically in homes or apartments, distinguishing them from more traditional lodgings like hotels. Under city code, short-term rentals may only operate in the Campus-Town Overlay District or C-2 General Business District zones without needing a special use permit to do so. Generally, those zones are just east of Northwest Missouri State University and also downtown. Operating in any other zone requires a special use permit, which necessitates a hearing with the Planning and Zoning Commission and then approval by the City Council.

The city has been eyeing short-term rentals more closely since February, when city officials began an outreach campaign to try and reduce the number of short-term rentals that were operating without a permit, including in zones where neighbors should have had an opportunity to weigh in. At the time, city officials also said that many property owners were unaware that their short-term rentals needed to be registered with the city and that a 5% transient guest tax was not being remitted to the city automatically by Airbnb.

Prior to that renewed scrutiny, the council had rarely rejected special use permit applications, even as the city grapples with an affordable housing shortage that was one of the top concerns it is looking to address in a new master planning document.

During a Planning and Zoning Commission hearing on Sept. 16, several neighbors spoke against approving the special use permit, with one saying the property was loud and another saying the neighborhood was supposed to be a family area. Neighbors had also complained about disruptive behavior at the 730 Prather property when opposing a proposed short-term rental at 724 Prather Ave. in January. The council rejected that application, and rejected the application on Monday as well due to the significant neighborhood opposition.

Council members did approve a special use permit application by Phillip and Diane Jensen for a short-term rental at 1021 Elm St. because no neighbors said they opposed the permit.

RV park

The other rejected special use permit application came from R Double T Holdings, which proposed to turn part of the land it owns at 1021 Wilson Industrial Road into an RV park. RV parks are not allowed by right in any zone and so require a special use permit.

On behalf of the Maryville Industrial Development Corporation, Josh McKim urged the council to reject the application. Among other functions designed to attract industry to Maryville, MIDC offers land to potential buyers who will use it for industrial developments.

“We are not in favor of establishing residential units within an active industrial park,” McKim said on behalf of MIDC. “We think that could be very difficult on our industrial partners, but also difficult on anyone who chooses to stay there or live there, whether that be on a short-term or longer term period.”

McKim said that MIDC sold five acres in the industrial park on Wilson Industrial Road to R Double T in 2022. The company has a storage building and an office building on the site. The agreement included an option to purchase an additional five acres at the site, which R Double T triggered in July.

But instead of using the site for industrial development, as intended, the company applied for the special use permit with the intention of turning it into an RV park with 25 spots to start and the potential to expand up to 100. The application said the RV spots would be needed for construction crews anticipated to work on the White Cloud Acres data center project. The company proposed to have the special use permit expire in seven years, when the land could be vacated and redeveloped.

McKim said MIDC had not been aware of the company’s plans.

Leave a Comment