Hershberger wins prosecutor race in high-turnout primary

GEOFFREY WOEHLK/THE FORUM
David Hershberger speaks at the Greater Maryville Chamber of Commerce’s Summer Candidate Forum on July 15. Hershberger won the Republican primary for Nodaway County Prosecuting Attorney on Tuesday with more than 74 percent of the vote, according to unofficial vote totals from the Nodaway County Clerk’s Office.
MARYVILLE, Mo. — David Hershberger defeated incumbent Nodaway County Prosecuting Attorney Tina Deiter in Tuesday’s primary election, and county voters followed statewide trends on rejecting Amendments 4 and 5.
The Republican race for prosecutor was the only contested local race in the primary election, and no Democrat will appear on the November general election ballot, clearing the way for Hershberger. Unofficial vote totals released Tuesday showed Hershberger won with more than 74 percent of the vote.
Deiter has served as county prosecutor since 2023 after she ran unopposed for the post. Throughout his campaign, Hershberger, a newcomer to Nodaway County, hammered her on two incidents that Deiter was widely criticized for on social media.
The first involved NOCOMO Industries, a sheltered workshop that provides work opportunities to people with disabilities. The organization’s former general manager, Nicki Samson, and chief financial officer, Margaret Helzer, were charged by Deiter’s office in 2023 with illegally funneling $483,000 from NOCOMO into retirement accounts for themselves and family members.
In August 2024, the NOCOMO Board of Trustees slammed a plea deal Deiter’s office struck with Samson that resulted in no jail time, no admission of guilt and required her to pay $23,019.85 in restitution. The charges against Helzer were dismissed due to a lack of evidence, Deiter said at the time.
The second was Deiter’s decision later that year to not bring charges after a young St. Louis woman suffered a stillbirth at Mozingo Lake Recreation Park. Deiter said there was no evidence a crime was committed, just “a tragic stillbirth.”
Other ballot items
Elsewhere on the ballot, Nodaway County voters followed statewide trends in soundly rejecting Amendments 4 and 5, and similarly, Republican voters in the county favored Chris Stigall to succeed Sam Graves as U.S. Representative in the Sixth District.
Amendment 4 would have made it more difficult for citizen-led amendments to get on the ballot. More than 78 percent of Nodaway County voters rejected the amendment. Amendment 5, which would have paved the way to eliminating the state income tax and allowed the state legislature to expand state sales taxes, was voted down by county voters by an even wider margin with nearly 87 percent voting no.
In the five-way Republican race to represent the Sixth District in Congress, Chris Stigall, a talk radio show host endorsed by Graves, won Nodaway County with nearly 46 percent of the vote. Nathan Willett, a Kansas City Councilman, was second with nearly 37 percent. Stigall won the districtwide contest as well.
On the Democratic side, Josh Smead outpaced Scot Pondelick and Matt Levine with more than 61 percent of the vote, and will face Stigall in November.
PRIMARY TURNOUT
Nodaway County voter turnout in August primary elections.
2020: 37.76%
2022: 36.00%
2024: 35.67%
2026: 40.45%*
*Unofficial results
SOURCE: NODAWAY COUNTY CLERK’S OFFICE
Turnout
The amendments along with the races for prosecuting attorney and Congress seemed to drive turnout for the August primary to a higher level than usual. More than 40 percent of registered Nodaway County voters went to the polls, the highest primary turnout since at least 2020, according to data from the Nodaway County Clerk’s Office.
About 76 percent of Nodaway County ballots cast in Tuesday’s primary were Republican, the first time that total has dipped below 80 percent for an August primary since 2020, when approximately 72 percent were Republican ballots.
