Skip to content

Column: Dissecting my MIAA preseason poll against the coaches, media polls

JON DYKSTRA/THE FORUM
The MIAA football coaches at Media Day in Topeka on Monday were; top from left; Missouri Southern’s Atiba Bradley, Northwest’s John McMenamin, Pittsburg State’s Tom Anthony, Nebraska-Kearney’s Ryan Held, Missouri Western’s Tyler Fenwick; bottom; Washburn’s Zach Watkins, Central Missouri’s Josh Lamberson, Central Oklahoma’s Adam Dorrel, Fort Hays State’s Chris Brown and Emporia State’s Garin Higgins.

Each year at MIAA Media Day, the highly-anticipated MIAA preseason poll comes out and this season, it was a rare split decision — a split-faced decision in fact.

Last season’s co-conference champions Pittsburg State and Northwest Missouri State each finished two games ahead of third-place Central Oklahoma and were unsurprisingly the top two teams in both the media and coaches preseason MIAA polls. The order was flipped with the Gorillas topping the coaches poll and the Bearcats taking the top spot in the media poll.

I filled out my own ballot for the media poll which was factored in so let’s look at where I agree and differ with the two sets of rankings.

Tier 1: Bluebloods

1. Northwest Missouri State

Media: 1; Coaches: 2

The Bearcats had a surprise rise back to the top of the MIAA last season. After losing the opener to Minnesota State, Northwest rattled off wins all the way until the season finale loss to Pittsburg State. The biggest area of growth was the rushing offense which went from eighth in the MIAA at 110 yards per game to to first by nearly 50 yards over anyone else with 243 yards per game. That unit returns its three leading rushers with Quincy Torry, Zechariah Owens and Te’Shaun Porter and the offensive line returns four starters led by All-American left tackle Kaleb McCullough.

The offense returns a ton and it is the defense with six new starters, but defensive coordinator Chad Bostwick has a group that’s rotated heavily and would be a surprise if it wasn’t among the best in the conference again after finishing as the top total and scoring defense last season.

2. Pittsburg State

Media: 2, Coaches: 1

Like Northwest’s defense, Pittsburg State’s entire team is going to have a lot of guys in new roles this season, but like the Bearcat defense, the Gorillas have earned the benefit of the doubt. I had Northwest at No. 1 because of the returning offensive firepower and their being less mystery there, but the coaches leaned on last season’s win for Pittsburg State over Northwest and put them in that spot.

Gorilla fans are going to need their program close by in the opening week with a ton of new facing in the lineup when reigning national champion Ferris State rolls into The Jungle on August 27. The linebacking duo of Blake Carr and Zach Coenen highlight the returners, but the new offensive backfield and offensive line is what has me pegging them just behind Northwest.

Tier 2: Fighting for Playoff Chatter

3. Central Missouri

Media: 4; Coaches: 5

I’m the highest on the Mules among the polls and maybe I’m missing something, but I see a real opportunity for them to compete with those first two teams.

It starts with coach Josh Lamberson’s bread and butter on offense, they ran two quarterbacks last season and I thought that senior Jordan Pachot proved to be the better one running their offense — broken foot and death in the family ended his season prematurely. With receivers Jake Weber, Marlon Lindsey and Jack Pospisil back, the offense should be explosive.

Defensively, former Northwest head coach Rich Wright built his 4-3 defense with inherited toys from a 3-4 defense. This season, he has more of his own guys and I expect that to show.

4. Fort Hays State

Media: 5; Coaches: 4

Every year, I’m higher on Fort Hays State than the consensus. This season, we are more aligned that previously.

I just know that there is a certain floor with Chris Brown’s Tigers. You know that the Tigers are going to play hard-nosed defense and be physical offensively.

They are trying to expand that narrative this season with adding reigning MIAA Offensive Player of the Year Jackson Berry from Pittsburg State. The new starting quarterback — I’ll call him that although Brown wouldn’t go that far at Media Day — got better and better as the year went on for the Gorillas. He will be a different look than Caleb Heavner, who went Division-I, was for the Tigers. Curtis Douglas is an experienced running back to return as well.

Defensively, the team is led by the best bookend defensive ends to return in the league with Gaven Haselhorst and Parrish Terry.

5. Central Oklahoma

Media: 3; Coaches: 3

If I’m higher on Central Missouri than everyone else, that means I’m lower on consensus with someone else and that team is Central Oklahoma. I understand the reason for optimism after the Bronchos were third in the MIAA and return one of the nation’s best quarterbacks with Jett Huff.

Adam Dorrel is also the ultimate proven winner at head coach, but with so much unproven around Huff and Dorrel, the No. 4 spot is as high as I could go. Dev Mathews ran the ball well last season in a time-share and inherits the full-time role this season, but the pass-catching options will have a new look, as will the defense.

6. Nebraska-Kearney

Media: 7; Coaches: 7

Isaiah Harris is back in the backfield for the Lopers. With Harris in the backfield last season, Nebraska-Kearney was 4-1 with a 34-20 win over Emporia State where Harris ran for 270 yards and four touchdowns.

Abram Scholting also returns at quarterback and Stone Wilson adds to the running back depth.

Parker Wise was the team’s top defensive player last season with 70 tackles, five sacks and an interception.

The Lopers have surpassed my previous preseason projections before and if they do that again, it would be a heck of a year in Ryan Held’s fourth season.

7. Emporia State

Media: 6; Coaches: 6

Media Day wasn’t even over and I was regretting having the dean of MIAA coaches this low. Garin Higgins goes into his 20th season as the head Hornet and he’s got his passing game back with a key re-addition. I think I’m going to regret putting Emporia State this low — even though this tier is a tier for a reason and I think 3-7 will be a jumbled mess, similar to last season.

Ben Harris was injured late last season, but the passing offense was humming at 296 yards per game with him last season. That was with Trenden Collins missing all but one game. The year prior, Collins had 791 yards receiving. Malik O’Atis stepped in to the void and had 717 yards in route to a First Team All-MIAA season.

Defensively, the team returns the MIAA Defensive Player of the Year with linebacker Landon Boss making 100 tackles, 17.5 tackles for loss and 10 sacks. Safety Tyler Schultze is another of the league’s top defenders.

Emporia State goes to the Jungle for the second game of the season — an upset of the Gorillas would open a lot of eyes.

Tier 3: Looking For Growth

8. Washburn

Media: 8; Coaches: 8

The bottom three were consensus among myself and the two polls. All three are very different situations. Washburn had the most positive end of the season with two wins and two field goal losses among their final five games. Every loss was one score except Northwest, Pittsburg State and Emporia State.

Sophomore quarterback Logan Madden returns as well as senior Justin Lewis. Whichever wins the camp battle gives the team an experienced triggerman for the spread attack. Tight ends Ty Weber and Henry Mohrman lead the returning pass catchers.

JC Heim is the best returning linebacker in the MIAA other than Emporia State’s Landon Boss. Heim had 142 tackles last season.

There are questions in Topeka, but the second year of the Zach Watkins era could be a launching pad for the future.

9. Missouri Western

Media: 9; Coaches: 9

It is clearly a prove-it year for fourth-year coach Tyler Fenwick. Last year’s 3-8 record is the worst season for the Griffons since a 2-8 campaign in 1990. After an 8-4 season in Fenwick’s first year and a 4-7 year in the second, the Griffons need to show positive momentum in Year 4.

Fenwick has had success at both Missouri S&T and Southeastern Oklahoma State before coming to St. Joseph. He was 37-28 at S&T and 16-19 at Southeastern Oklahoma (including a rebuilding 1-10 season his first year).

The Griffons return no one who threw a pass last season and will be looking to rebuild the passing game. Rickie Dunn showed flashes at running back last season with 198 yards.

The defense’s strength is up the middle with defensive lineman Deontrae Young and linebackers Kienen Gaskin, Khalid Sereal and Broc Worcester.

Augustana and Central Missouri in the first two games give the Griffons a chance to show their improvement.

10. Missouri Southern

Media: 10; Coaches: 10

I bought a lot of Missouri Southern stock the last couple years and it flopped the last couple years.

I still firmly believe that Atiba Bradley is the right man for the job, but I don’t envy him the job of rebuilding the program in Joplin. Bradley’s teams have shown flashes, but the consistency has lacked.

As a true freshman, Tillman Martin showed he can play with 2,506 passing yards. Martin could be the main character in the turnaround over the next three seasons. But there are just too many questions around him with only five returning starters to rank them any higher.

Midwestern State and Upper Iowa in the first two games gives the Lions a shot for some momentum coming into the MIAA opener in Maryville.

Skye Pournazari
Jon Dykstra Managing Editor The Maryville Forum

Leave a Comment