Forum Editorial: Short-term rentals hurt long-term housing outlook

EDITORIAL MUG: Editorial art Vertical
In a briefing to the City Council last week, City Manager Ryan Heiland revealed that most owners of short-term rentals have not registered their properties as required and that many do not pay the required 5 percent transient guest tax, as hotels do.
While we agree this is obviously a problem and are grateful the city is taking steps to resolve it, we believe the significant number of short-term rentals in town only exacerbates an ongoing housing crisis that government officials and business leaders all agree is a major threat to our future as a community.
First, let’s talk about how the system works. Since 2019, anyone who owns property within the Campus Town Overlay District or C-2 General Business District, which are generally east of the university and includes downtown, can set up a short-term rental — like an Airbnb — without having to get a special permit to do so. The thinking is that because those areas aren’t zoned for family residential living, a short-term rental would fit with the purpose of the zoning and not disrupt a neighborhood.
In all other zones, a property owner must submit a special use permit application, which triggers notification of nearby residents in case they want to object. Then the Planning and Zoning Commission conducts a hearing and recommends to the City Council whether the application should be approved before the council makes the final decision.
The current ruleset is reasonable if the aim is to maintain existing neighborhood integrity. But we believe that won’t be enough.
A laborshed study released last year, commissioned by the city and county, showed that the lack of affordable housing in our region is one of the biggest barriers to bringing new workers to Nodaway County. Specifically, a rental market geared toward jamming in as many college students as possible along with a dearth of starter homes available for purchase make our community unnecessarily difficult for young families to put down roots. Heads of the county’s largest employers have made it clear multiple times over the past few years that potential new employees struggle to find places to live.
That’s why, despite the project’s eventual shortcomings, we stand by our praise of the Maryville Industrial Development Corporation for its pilot program that put a manufactured home on Buchanan Street in late 2024. Ultimately, this probably didn’t turn out to be a viable, large-scale solution. But we’ve got to try something.
Generally, we believe that every American should be able to do what they want with their property. As long as what you want to do doesn’t interfere with anyone else doing what they want to do, government should largely stay out of it.
But we encourage city officials to take a very strict view of future special use permit applications for short-term rentals, including for the 10 or more properties The Forum found last week that appeared to be operating without a required permit. Turning existing residential houses and apartments into short-term rentals keeps those homes off the market for people who want to live and work here. That’s exactly the opposite of what our community needs right now, regardless of what neighborhood you live in.
As the city assembles its next comprehensive plan, we encourage city officials to not just study strategies that disincentivize short-term rentals, but instead to focus on creative, proactive solutions that incentivize property owners to rent or sell their properties to long-term residents over temporary visitors. We believe that should include discussion of tax abatements and freezes for those property owners in the same vein as the deals employers regularly receive for providing jobs that, increasingly, they can no longer adequately fill. And the city should similarly consider shifting some of its limited grant resources from helping some Airbnb owners improve their buildings to helping property owners in the rest of the city improve their properties on the promise they be used for single-family housing.
We don’t claim to know the best course. But we can be sure there is no solution coming from Jefferson City or Washington.
We must figure out for ourselves what kind of community we will be in 20 years: One where families come to live, or one where they are just visiting.
