City looking to enforce short-term rental regs

City of Maryville logo
MARYVILLE, Mo. — The city of Maryville is starting to address unregulated short-term rentals, including those that are not registered, have not received a special use permit or have not paid proper taxes.
During the regular City Council meeting on Monday, City Manager Ryan Heiland said all three of the above issues have run rampant since the council passed a short-term rental ordinance in 2019 to address the growing industry.
Short-term rentals, like Airbnbs, allow guests to stay for short periods, typically in homes or apartments, distinguishing them somewhat from hotels. Under city ordinance, every short-term rental must be registered with the city and must remit the city’s 5-percent transient guest tax that is also levied on hotels. Additionally, short-term rentals may only operate in the Campus-Town Overlay District or C-2 General Business zones of the city by right, which means only registration with the city is required in those zones. Outside of those zones, which respectively are generally east of the university and downtown, owners of short-term rentals must apply for and receive a special use permit.
That process includes notifying neighbors, giving them the opportunity to give feedback to the Planning and Zoning Commission, and then to the City Council, which must ultimately approve every special use permit. Since the ordinance was passed in 2019, the council has approved 12 permits, according to previous Forum reporting.
SHORT-TERM RENTAL SNAPSHOT
The Forum checked Maryville Airbnb listings Tuesday night. Here’s what we found:
- 36 unique addresses
- 20 unregistered
- 10 without required special use permit
A preliminary analysis by The Forum of listings on Airbnb and Vrbo, two popular short-term rental sites, found 36 unique property addresses listed within Maryville city limits as of Tuesday evening. Of those properties, a little more than half appeared to be unregistered, according to city documents provided to The Forum. Of the 20 unregistered properties, at least 10 appeared to be in zones that should have required a special use permit to legally operate. Those 36 properties included two hotels that appear to list rooms on short-term rental services and at least one apartment building that had seven apartments currently listed.
That analysis includes only the properties that were listed on Tuesday evening and does not necessarily include all short-term rentals that regularly or occasionally operate within city limits. City records indicate that 21 individual addresses have active short-term rental registrations.
ANALYSIS METHODOLOGY
The Forum checked all listings on Airbnb Tuesday night that were within Maryville city limits. To protect privacy, Airbnb does not provide exact addresses in the listings, only a radius in which the property is located. The Forum used photos and comments on the listings to match to available Google Street View images or other data that indicated an exact address, then crosschecked the location with a city zoning map. Only properties with verified exact addresses were included in the number of properties that appear to be operating without a required special use permit.
On Monday, Heiland said that even many of the operators of the 21 registered properties have not been properly paying the transient guest tax because of confusion with Airbnb. According to Heiland, Airbnb automatically adds local sales taxes properly to listings. Consequently, many short-term rental owners believed the transient guest tax was included. However, Heiland said that’s not the case.
Assistant Finance Director Cheyenne Murphy said that when she managed to make contact with Airbnb, the company refused to begin adding the tax, though it has done so in larger areas, like Kansas City, she said. However, Airbnb did agree to send a copy of the city’s ordinance to each user who listed a property in Maryville.
Additionally, the city sent letters to at least 15 of the registered property owners, who have largely been very cooperative, Heiland said. That leads city officials to believe that an education campaign will probably be very effective — the biggest problem, they believe, is simply that property owners don’t know that they are in violation of any ordinances.
Enforcement beyond that would be tricky, Heiland said. Unlike many other municipalities, Maryville does not require businesses to obtain a license, for example. In other cities, Heiland said, revoking a business license would be a key enforcement step if short-term rentals don’t remit the transient guest tax properly.
Heiland said staff will continue to work on getting short-term rental owners more information on how to come into compliance and will likely come back to the council with some ordinance update proposals as well.
