Bearcats’ fifth-straight winning season ends with tie, penalty shootout

JON DYKSTRA/THE FORUM
The Bearcats celebrate around senior Margaret Madden after her goal Sunday in St. Joseph.
ST. JOSEPH, Mo. — Before this group of Northwest Missouri State soccer seniors arrived on campus, the team had never had more than two winning seasons in a row.
Lily Ellis, Margaret Madden and Moira Franck joined after the Bearcats made their first NCAA Tournament appearance in 2021 and immediately followed with another in 2022, which was the best season in team history at 13-5-3. They rattled off three more winning seasons alongside fellow senior Abby Overbay and Northwest has developed its winning culture with 5-straight seasons above .500.
“This is definitely the most unexpected and best experience that I’ve ever had,” Ellis said. “I didn’t expect to come to Northwest, but it was one of the best decisions I’ve ever made. I would do it 10 times again if I could.”
This season ends at 10-6-2 with a 1-1 tie at Missouri Western where the Griffons advanced to to the MIAA semifinals with a 4-3 advantage in penalty kicks after two overtime sessions.
Fourth-seeded Missouri Western advances to Thursday’s semifinals as the highest seed remaining in the MIAA Tournament after the three top seeds were all upset on Sunday in the quarterfinals.
Fifth-seeded Northwest nearly added to that upset mix and would’ve been the top seed remaining. The Bearcats got on the board early after a corner kick sequence led to a MaKenna West shot and floating ball which found the head of Madden.
Madden put it into the back of the net in the 11th minute for a 1-0 lead.
“When I saw it pop in the air, I know that heading is my speciality — I like getting everything in the air,” Madden said. “I just kinda had that feeling that I was going to be able to put it away and that is exactly what happened.”
Northwest went into defensive mode from there and the Bearcats kept the Griffons off the board despite 15 corner kicks in the game, but the shots ended up being mostly from long range and not challenging Ellis, who had 11 saves.
The game turned with just under seven minutes left on a yellow-card call on Norah Oyler that the Bearcat coaching staff and fans questioned loudly. The Griffons took the free kick and put it into the box.
Ellis came out aggressively to grab the ball, but got blocked from it and the ball eventually found Aliyn Woodall, who put the ball in the open net.
“A little mistake by me with about six minutes left,” Ellis said. “A mistake they capitalized on.”
Northwest subbed back in leading scorer West, who sat much of the game after missing the last three with a hamstring injury. West injected energy into the offense, but the Bearcats were unable to regain their offensive rhythm as regulation and two overtime sessions passed.
“I felt like that we were trying to find a rhythm, but then it was done and we were into overtime,” Northwest coach Marc Gordon said.
Ellis opened the penalty kicks with a save and Emma Cook and Ximena Arnau made theirs to have a 2-0 lead. The Griffons answered with four-straight makes and Northwest missed two of its final three for a 4-3 Griffon win.
“The penalties — it is a lottery once you get to that,” Gordon said. “I thought that both keepers were good.”
Northwest is slated to return a big chunk of its roster, but will miss the contributions of Ellis, Madden, Franck and Overbay.
“They are my best friends,” Ellis said. “We’ve been through a lot of stuff together and they’ve always stuck by me. It is just awesome that we could join each other on the field for one last time.”

