Skip to content

Forum Editorial: Water plant relocation was only decision

EDITORIAL MUG: Editorial art Vertical

Last week, project leaders told the Maryville City Council that the new water treatment plant will have to be built alongside the existing facility on U.S. Highway 136 along the One Hundred and Two River instead of at Mozingo Lake because of skyrocketing costs.

Rightfully, City Council members Erin Allen and John McBride questioned why the prohibitively high costs hadn’t been factored in to begin with. The answers, we felt, were satisfactory. Until the construction manager at-risk was hired in April, plans were still very preliminary and hadn’t been assigned real-world costs yet. The point of using a construction manager at-risk model is to find these things out by having the construction contractor involved during the design stage so that this kind of surprise doesn’t happen at the very end when the project has been designed and put out to bid. In that sense, the system worked as intended — better to find out now than later.

However, we think Ms. Allen and Mr. McBride were speaking for their constituents when they pressed project leaders for more information, and applaud them for doing so in an open forum. The fact is, voters were told in February when they approved a $50 million bond that this facility would go in at Mozingo Lake, the city’s water source, rather than where the current plant is located. This project was supposed to eliminate the compromises that have been necessary over the past few decades when the plant on the One Hundred and Two River was retrofitted to handle water from the lake instead of the river. Now, the project has begun with one.

With all that being said, we encourage those who are understandably a little put off to take a breath — or a sip of water.

Perhaps some would not have voted for the new facility if the original plan had been to build it at the current site. But we would have. Information on why this new plant is essential to our future has been far from scant, and those issues haven’t changed.

Ultimately, it’s immaterial to most of us where the plant is located. Will it solve our water taste and odor issues more efficiently? Yes. Will it be more resilient and better tailored to treating lake water? Yes. Will it set our community up for decades of water treatment security? Yes.

On top of that, the change in location keeps the project within the voter-approved budget — which is good, because we don’t have the tens of millions more it would cost otherwise.

To us, it’s clear this was the right decision for our community’s future.

Leave a Comment