Skip to content

Judge to rule soon on Hopkins motions to dismiss clerks’ cases

FORUM FILE PHOTO
4-5-18 Hopkins city hall building

MARYVILLE, Mo. — Fourth Circuit Presiding Judge Corey Herron told attorneys Monday afternoon that he would have a decision regarding a motion to dismiss two cases involving the city of Hopkins within the next two weeks.

Former clerks, Theodore Phipps and Krystal Bowen have filed two separate cases against the city.

Phipps, a former city clerk of Hopkins, filed a lawsuit against the city in January claiming city leaders discriminated against him and denied him whistleblower protection during his employment from Feb. 1, 2021 to April 4, 2024.

Bowen, a former assistant clerk of the city, filed suit at the same time, alleging she was discriminated against, was the target of a hostile work environment and was unlawfully terminated on or about March 8, 2024.

During Monday’s hearing, Jill Smith, attorney for the city of Hopkins, argued that the basic number of employees listed in the plaintiff’s filings is too small to meet the definition of an employer according to state statute.

On behalf of Phipps, attorney Robert Murphy said that arguing facts at this point in the case is not yet warranted and that a period of discovery is required.

Smith suggested that the lawsuit may not even be under consideration under the correct statute.

In the petition filed Jan. 27 in the 4th Circuit Court, Phipps alleged that he was repeatedly exposed to “abusive and offensive conduct” by a coworker that triggered episodes of post-traumatic stress disorder that Phipps said he was diagnosed with due to his service in the Air Force.

The lawsuit describes the coworker as “the operations manager for the city who also held a license necessary to operate the city’s wastewater plant.”

In the petition filed by Bowen, she claims that in her ninth month of pregnancy, “The operations manager scandalously and openly questioned whether the city treasurer, rather than her fiancée, was the father of her unborn child,” among other defamatory comments that were “rude, offensive, demeaning and mean-spirited.” The petition also claims that the mayor and aldermen failed and refused to stop the hostile work environment.

Herron said he would take the matter under advisement and make a decision within the next couple of weeks.

Update

As of June 18 and according to online court documents made available after deadline, Judge Corey Herron denied the city of Hopkins’ motion to dismiss.

Correction

This article originally and incorrectly stated that Phipps and Bowen were in a relationship, due to a reporter’s error. The Forum apologizes for this error.

Leave a Comment