Forum Editorial: Factory-built home ordinance is good first step

EDITORIAL MUG: Editorial art Vertical
We applaud the city of Maryville for implementing a sensible solution for regulating factory-built homes.
The ordinance passed by the council on Monday will ensure that neighborhoods have a much greater say in the future over whether manufactured homes are allowed near them. We also acknowledge that the ordinance, unfortunately, won’t do much to alleviate the concerns of the neighbors on and around the Buchanan Street manufactured home that began the whole process since that home is already in place.
Like many, we initially endorsed the Maryville Industrial Development Corporation’s plan to place manufactured homes in Hopkins and Maryville as an affordable housing pilot program aimed at manufacturing workers. It’s not getting any easier for hardworking families to start a life in a home of their own, and so we believe in the need for creative solutions from all angles.
Again, like many, we also took seriously the complaints of neighbors who felt the manufactured home plopped down next to them would not only devalue their own property, but also affect the aesthetics of the neighborhood. There is no way around the fact that the MIDC dropped the ball on a key part of the pilot program: buy-in from the community.
But they aren’t the only ones. We failed to contextualize what a manufactured home actually was even though we reported on the program — and the MIDC’s intention to use manufactured homes — months before the home ever arrived. We must do better in ensuring public officials and the community they serve know what they’re getting.
One of the drawbacks of looking for solutions from all angles is that it discourages true collaboration. While the MIDC worked with employers and banks to try and come up with a program that is affordable and benefits the community, the siloed nature of non-public efforts to solve communitywide problems means that not everyone has a seat at the table. The best way to make sure the manufactured home situation does not happen again is to make future efforts more public-facing endeavors that integrate the voices of those who actually need to buy a house or secure long-term employment.
But as we are looking for ways to show workers that Maryville is a place they can start and raise a family, the predominant voices in the room are owners and employers — those looking to sell, not looking to buy. Yes, of course we need their voices. We need to know what’s affordable to them and what they can do to help create an environment conducive to long-term community growth.
But amid all that, there is very little mechanism for others to point out the angle they’re coming from. For example, in an MIDC board meeting, a $200,000 price tag for the manufactured home must have sounded reasonable. They consulted with employers that employ the workers and banks that make the loans. And maybe it is — that’s the point of a pilot program. But as the news was disseminated into the rest of the community, that number produced quite a few scoffs, including from a City Council member, while the home’s future neighbors were rightfully angry that no one bothered asking their opinion at all.
We need a variety of ideas to help alleviate a housing crisis that goes far beyond Maryville. Ultimately what we can do is limited. But our community has often shown how concerted, forward-thinking efforts can result in larger dividends than might have been initially thought possible.
To make that happen again with housing, our community leaders, public and private, must open up future efforts at an earlier stage to involve more members of our community from all corners.
Additionally, we believe city leaders should take a more active role in shaping what kind of housing we want to be available in Maryville. Much of how the city has regulated housing so far has been reactive — which, normally, we think is a sound strategy. We believe government should be largely hands-off: Generally, as long as you’re not impeding someone else, you should be able to do what you want with your property.
But we must all deal with the consequences of a town where what so many property owners want to do with their property is cram in as many college students as possible, or turn a formerly family home into an AirBNB — both in areas creeping far beyond campus. There’s a reason so much of Maryville’s workforce does not live in Maryville.
When the city soon begins gathering input on a new comprehensive plan to guide decision-making over the next two decades or so, we believe finding a better balance should be top of mind for our collective future.
In the meantime, the solutions we have are not perfect, but they are the best we can manage. And, like we have proven so many times before, we’re confident that we will find a way forward as long as we continue doing our best — and doing it together.
