A Word from Woehlk: Why we’re OK with the death penalty

Skye Pournazari
A Word from Woehlk: Why we’re OK with the death penalty
Tuesday night, we killed somebody, you and I. Well, you, me and everybody else in the state.
We killed a guy named Marcellus Williams.
Do you feel any different? I don’t.
I would tell you more about Marcellus Williams, but really, I don’t know anything about him. Oh sure, I’ve seen headlines, so I was aware that we were going to kill him. But I never read anything more than that, to be honest (not that anyone else does that sort of thing with news stories…right?). So I’m vaguely aware that some people strongly believed that there was some doubt over his…doing whatever he did. I don’t actually know, though I assume it must’ve been a particularly grisly type of murder if we killed him for it, right?
Honestly, I don’t really care what he did. And really, I don’t even care if he was innocent. It doesn’t matter to me either way.
You, me and the state shouldn’t be allowed to kill people. Period.
Bold position, I know.
There’s probably plenty of reasons to be against the death penalty. Some folks are fine with us killing the right people, but they get understandably squeamish about the nearly 200 death row exonerations since 1975, including three last year.
But truthfully, that’s not me.
Other folks might be against the death penalty in general because they feel it’s morally wrong. It’s kinda high up on the Top 10 list God left behind after all. I mean, not number-wise, but surely in order of what’s actually important to him, right? I think we can all agree he was cool with a little pigskin on the sabbath, but the killing thing, I dunno…just seems like he was probably a little more serious about that one. Or so some people believe.
But to me, that doesn’t really matter either, frankly. Not like we killed the guy on a Sunday.
Marcellus Williams was, it turns out, the 100th person we’ve killed in Missouri since the death penalty was reinstituted in our state in 1989.
Be honest — you just thought to yourself, “huh, that’s not that many,” didn’t you?
I wonder what number it would have to get up to for us to say the opposite? A few hundred? A thousand?
It’s not near the top of the list, but one of the ways I would describe myself is as “raised Catholic” — which, in Catholicism, means I don’t go to church anymore and eat meat on Fridays during Lent, but still feel guilty about it and have a certain snootiness toward denominations that worship somewhere that has a “multipurpose room.”
It also means, though, like anyone raised in any values-based system, that I have no excuse not to know the innate and irrevocable value of each and every human soul.
I don’t know anything about Marcellus Williams, about any of the unforgivable things he did, or anything about the ways in which there is apparently plenty of doubt about whether he did any of them at all. I don’t have to know anything about Marcellus Williams to know that he had a soul.
Has a soul, if I’m feeling particularly non-secular.
Apparently, though, his was just a little cheaper than other people’s, I guess. I dunno, I didn’t know the guy.
So even that isn’t why I think we have no right to kill people.
No, instead it’s that tonight, I’m gonna sleep just fine. Honestly, I’m probably never going to think of Marcellus Williams again. It’s kind of an amazing coincidence I ever thought about him at all as it is. How many of the other 99 people we’ve killed did I ever know the name of? Except maybe one or two of them, we killed them and I had no idea they had ever even existed, much less had been executed in my name. How many can you remember? Or ever knew about to begin with?
And you know what?
I still don’t really care. Tomorrow, I’m going to worry about all the normal things, get frustrated with all the regular frustrations, and give not even a thought to how many more times we’re going to be fine with killing someone together.
And make no mistake, we’re absolutely responsible. That’s not just residual Catholic guilt.
When was the last time I even looked up a candidate’s position on capital punishment? When was the last time you heard a politician say much at all about it? When was the last time you based your vote on it? When was the last time it was even on the political radar as a significant issue? And when was the last time I, in all my professional opportunities speaking with elected officials, ever once asked, “Hey, which people do you think it’s OK for us to kill and when?”
I dunno about you, but I don’t need a whole lotta fingers to count ’em up. How’d you do?
And the worst part is, I’m still not going to change anything. Are you? We’re going to kill more people, or we aren’t. Maybe I’ll see a headline about it, or maybe I won’t.
People like you and me, we shouldn’t be allowed to decide whose soul is worth more than others’, and who should live and who should die. Should we? Should our state government?
I’m against the death penalty without exception because I know how little it affects me whether we are killing people or not killing people.
And since we are killing people, then…shouldn’t it? Even just a little?
Tonight, it’s not Marcellus Williams’ soul I’m worried about.
But then, it never was. So why change now?
Geoffrey Woehlk is the news editor at The Forum.
