Skip to content

Column: Deep diving into the 8-man football poll

Skye Pournazari
Jon Dykstra Managing Editor The Maryville Forum

As one of seven voters in the Missouri 8-Man Football Poll, I take my vote there very seriously and try to do ample research every week to make my vote as accurate as possible.

Up until this week, that involved my ballot not changing much due to the small sample size and unless a team loses, they weren’t dropping. The plan was always that this week would be the week to basically start over and reevaluate everyone based on a 4-week sample size.

I did that this week and here is my personal top-10, which I submitted for the poll. I also included my other “contenders,” which includes at least one team from each district to give everyone an idea of what the postseason may look like.

The official poll is: 1. Archie, 2. Nodaway Valley, 3. Braymer, 4. Bishop LeBlond, 5. Albany, 6. South Holt, 7. Lockwood, 8. Appleton City, 9. Platte Valley, 10. Worth County. But here is my ballot:

1. Nodaway Valley (4-0)

275; District 6

Wins: North Andrew (42-16); King City (38-20); East Atchison (42-18); Platte Valley (58-20)

The Thunder have been the most impressive team so far this season, and honestly I don’t think it’s been that close. Their lines have always been their strength led by Garrett Carpenter and Ben Cordell. The addition of Lane Larabee at quarterback unlocks the offense with weapons like Tye Hoyt and Jax Cowden.

2. Archie (4-0)

WEMO; District 2

Wins: Lockwood (48-38); Appleton City (54-42); Rich Hill (64-8); Osceola (56-6)

The 2-3 debate is an awesome one. I give the edge to Archie because of two top-10 wins over Appleton City and Lockwood. They replaced a lot from the state champion team, but Archie has certainly proven they are still the class of the south.

3. Braymer (4-0)

CRL; District 4

Wins: Concordia (52-27); SW Livingston (78-18); Paris (63-38); St. Paul Lutheran (85-32)

Braymer has been my No. 1 team all season until this week, but they haven’t had the chance to show as much as Archie and Nodaway Valley yet. I still want to see how they fare against teams with elite line play. It didn’t go well last year, but this year has a chance to be different. They just haven’t had the chance to show it yet.

4. Albany (4-0)

GRC; District 7

Wins: Stewartsville-Osborn (66-6); East Atchison (58-48); St. Joseph Christian (42-20); Worth County (36-34)

Speaking of showing something, Albany got that chance last week and went and made a statement in Grant City. The Warriors picked up the 36-34 win to take command of the GRC race. There aren’t many “triplet” combinations as dangerous as Chase Cline, Elliot Mercer and Kyle Emerson.

5. Bishop LeBlond (4-0)

Independent; District 5

Wins: North Shelby (56-30); Schuyler County (72-12); Knox County (52-28); Plattsburg (60-12)

Others have Bishop LeBlond even higher on this list. I’ve been hesitant to move them up with a below .500 year last season and without a top-10 team played so far. The North Shelby and Plattsburg wins are good wins though. Pull something off against Archie this week and we will be having a discussion between them and Nodaway Valley. Let’s see that game though first.

6. Platte Valley (3-1)

275; District 7

Wins: Worth County (12-6); Princeton (74-34); Mound City (52-6)

Loss: Nodaway Valley (58-20)

The first 1-loss team checks in here. Obviously the loss is to my No. 1 team, so that’s as quality of a loss as it gets. They have been crushed by injuries this season, but still have a ton of talent led by Justin Miller, Landon Wiederholt and Lucky Ferry. That District 7 still looks like a bloodbath. Platte Valley has one of the better wins in the state already too with a win over Worth County.

7. South Holt (4-0)

275; District 6

Wins: Princeton (69-32); Pattonsburg (73-66); DeKalb (84-34); Stew/Oz (69-12)

The Knights have the best player in the state, in my opinion, with Cole Medsker. Their schedule so far has been among the worst in the state and a 7-point win over Pattonsburg is concerning. But they have Medsker and he always gives the Knights a chance.

8. Worth County (2-2)

GRC; District 7

Wins: Mound City (44-14); North Andrew (64-6)

Loss: Platte Valley (12-6); Albany (36-34)

I struggled with where to rank the Tigers. Many would probably say this is too high for a 2-2 team, but those two losses were a 6-point loss to my No. 6 team and a 2-point loss to my No. 4 team. They lack that signature win, but the Tigers have proven they are right there with those top-5 type teams.

9. Lockwood (3-1)

Independent; District 1

Wins: Drexel (62-24); Jasper (64-6); Greenfield (66-16)

Loss: Archie (48-38)

The southernmost of the south teams has been rolling since a close loss to Archie. Showing they can play with Archie is encouraging — similar to Worth County. They are the big-time favorite in District 1 to make the quarterfinals and earn that Archie rematch.

10. Appleton City (3-1)

WEMO; District 2

Wins: Greenfield (66-0); Drexel (44-26); Rich Hill (58-20)

Loss: Archie (54-42)

Cash Anderson is the best running back in the state. Just needed to say that first. Appleton City has an extremely similar resume to Lockwood with slightly less-impressive results. They will get the first shot at an Archie rematch in the district championship most likely.

In order of district:

Concordia (3-1)

CRL; District 3

Wins: Slater (49-20); Northwest Hughesville (37-0); SW Livingston (89-18)

Loss: Braymer (52-27)

The loss to Braymer seems to put a cap on Concordia’s ceiling, but they have also proven to be the class of their district. That Braymer rematch would be a state quarterfinal game.

Norborne-Hardin Central (4-0)

CRL; District 4

Wins: Sweet Springs (76-18); Wellington-Napoleon (52-46); Santa Fe (80-20); Orrick (46-20)

Undefeated is undefeated. The Aggies survived the Wellington-Napoleon game. They haven’t played anyone else on this list yet, so those ‘prove-it’ games are coming.

Plattsburg (2-1)

Independent; District 5

Wins: Knox County (68-32); Schuyler County (46-42)

Loss: LeBlond (60-12)

The Tigers crashed to Earth last week against LeBlond. They continue to adjust to 8-man life without Isaia Howard.

Rock Port (4-0)

275; District 6

Wins: Pattonsburg (62-60); Stanberry (44-22); Stewartsville-Osborn (70-0); DeKalb (54-0)

See the Norborne-Hardin Central section. The Jays are winning, but murderer’s row in the 275 Conference is coming. I am excited for those matchups and to see how Rock Port holds up. They are probably my No. 11 team if I extended my ballot.

North Shelby (3-1)

CRL; District 8

Wins: Sweet Springs (70-16); St. Paul Lutheran (84-22); Wellington-Napoleon (66-28)

Loss: Bishop LeBlond (56-30)

If Rock Port isn’t No. 11, it’s the Raiders. As LeBlond continues to win, my opinion of North Shelby continues to rise. They are still the team to beat in their district in my opinion.

Paris (3-1)

CRL; District 8

Wins: Keytesville (72-8); Orrick (42-0); Northland Christian (74-8)

Loss: Braymer (63-28)

Nice start to the season for Paris. The schedule hasn’t been great other than Braymer, but a 35-point spread against Braymer isn’t too bad by Braymer standards.

Leave a Comment