Laying out the evidence after renewed interest in Branson Perry case

Becky Klino Branson Perry’s Mother
MARYVILLE, Mo. — It’s been 23 years since Branson Perry left the front yard of his dad’s Skidmore home. But the search for answers hasn’t abated.
Although local, state and federal law enforcement officials did not find any new evidence at a dig last month in Quitman, the latest in the search for Perry has renewed interest in his case.
For the first time, The Forum has assembled information from available news reports and local investigators involved to lay out in one place how the case has unfolded since the 20-year-old Perry never came back home after leaving on April 11, 2001.
Vanished
On Wednesday, April 11, 2001, Branson and his longtime friend, Jena Crawford, were at his father’s home in Skidmore where Branson had been living with his dad, Bob Perry. They were cleaning and preparing for Bob to return home from a hospital stay that Friday.
Outside, two men were working on Bob’s car to replace the alternator, which had given out the day before, according to a post by Becky Klino, Perry’s mother, on her website, bringbransonhome.wordpress.com.
Most accounts of what happened at Perry’s home that day are credited to Crawford, but come at least secondhand from others who are recounting her versions of events.
Crawford declined to speak to The Forum for this story, citing concerns that she may have to testify in court someday about the case and that she did not want to say something in print that may someday complicate any court testimony she may give. Records of the case are still closed because it is considered an active investigation.
According to a plea that appears to date back to at least January 2007 written by Klino and posted on her website, Klino admitted that “the events of the day are fairly sketchy to me and often make no sense.”
“At one point, (Crawford) saw Branson run into the kitchen and take something out of one of the cabinets, then run out the back door,” Klino’s post continued. “When he returned, she said he wouldn’t tell her what he was doing and acted like nothing happened. Later, she said she had taken a shower and when she came out of the bathroom she saw one of the men that were working on the car going through the cabinets in the kitchen. She said she asked him what he was looking for and he told her nothing and went back outside. Then at approximately 3 PM she had been upstairs when she heard the front porch door shut. She looked out the window and saw Branson. She asked him where he was going and he told her he was going to put the jumper cables in the storage shed and would be right back. She never saw him again. The men that had been working on the car claim to have never seen him. No one saw him.”
That version of events generally lines up with what law enforcement officials have said publicly.
By Friday, Bob was not yet ready to come home as planned, and still no one had heard from Perry. That day, Perry’s grandmother, Jo Ann Stinnett, came to check the house and, according to Klino, found all the doors open and the radio on. No public account explains why Crawford or the two men may have left the house in that state when they departed on Wednesday, or if it was in that state when they left.
On Monday morning, April 16, five days after anyone had laid eyes on Perry, Klino met Bob and Stinnett at the Nodaway County Sheriff’s Office to file a missing person report, and the investigation began.
TIMELINE
April 11, 2001 – Branson Perry leaves his dad’s home in Skidmore and never returns.
April 13 or 14, 2001 – Probable date that a house in Quitman frequently used to buy drugs burns down.
April 16, 2001 – Perry is reported missing.
2002 – Jack Wayne Rogers is arrested by the FBI and agents find messages he sent seeming to describe how he tortured and murdered a man matching Perry’s description. Rogers denies ever encountering Perry and says it was a fantasy. No evidence was found connecting the two and charges were never brought in connection with Perry.
2004 – Perry’s father, Bob, dies.
2009 – A Holt County prisoner tips off authorities that he knows where Perry is buried. He leads them to a site in Quitman, but later recants after a two-day search in which nothing is found.
2011 – Perry’s mother, Becky Klino, dies. 2015 – Perry’s grandmother, Jo Ann Stinnett, dies.
2019 – Nodaway County Sheriff Randy Strong tells the St. Joseph News-Press that Perry was last seen at a house that burned down.
2022 – Strong announces that investigators have a suspect in the case, but don’t have enough evidence to bring charges without a body. 2024 – The Nodaway County Sheriff’s Office, Missouri State Highway Patrol, FBI and other agencies search a well in Quitman after receiving a “credible tip” connected to the Perry case. No new evidence is found.
‘Nobody was talking’
According to the 2006 book “Baby Be Mine: The Shocking True Story of a Woman Who Murdered a Pregnant Mother to Steal Her Child,” by Diane Fanning, about the murder of Perry’s cousin, Bobbie Jo Stinnett, Sheriff Ben Espey organized a search party in a 15-mile radius to try and find the missing 20-yearold, but turned up nothing.
The case’s first lead investigator was Steve Whittington, who worked at the Nodaway County Sheriff’s Office as a sergeant and investigator from 1997 to 2010.
In an interview with The Forum, Whittington said the investigation started with the basics, as most do.
“We just went … talking to people and just looking around, put out alerts and what have you, put out a missing person thing on him, and we never got any response at all back from that,” Whittington said.
Foul play wasn’t necessarily suspected at first. Perry wouldn’t have been the first 20-year-old to hitchhike away from a rural home without warning.
“We kept watching the bank account,” Whittington said. “He had money in the bank account and that never was touched. So, it wasn’t like he took off.”
But it was quickly clear that wherever Perry had gone, something had happened.
According to Klino’s account on her website, all of Perry’s belongings were still at home when investigators arrived, including his wallet. That is, except for the jumper cables, which police, Klino said, did not find in the nearby storage shed where Perry had said he was going to bring them.
Two weeks later, however, the cables were found “just inside the door” of the shed, though it’s unclear from Klino’s account who found them.
By that point, that case had already reached an impasse, and Whittington was now sure of one thing.
“Some foul play was definitely involved,” he told The Forum last month. “Especially when everything just went — it was cold, you know? And nobody was talking.”
That included the two men who were working on Bob Perry’s vehicle at the time Perry was last seen. According to Whittington, one of them was mechanic Bill Dragoo. Dragoo died in 2021.
“I always felt like Bill knew something about it, but he never would talk or anything,” Whittington said.
During that first year after Perry disappeared, Whittington said he recalled digging up a septic tank in Holt County, an area north of Skidmore, a spot in Quitman and that they searched as many wells as they could find, following up on leads and even the weakest rumors, just in case they could find something that would put them on the trail to Perry.
As time went on, with more than 100 interviews conducted in the two months or so after Perry had been reported missing, law enforcement agencies became more and more focused on his connections to the drug scene around Skidmore and Quitman, a small, unincorporated area about 6 miles to the south of Skidmore.
In particular, they focused on statements from witnesses who reportedly said that the last time Perry was seen wasn’t at his home in Skidmore, but later, at a house just east of Quitman.
The Quitman house
“I’m sure this is all tied to drugs,” Whittington told The Forum 23 years later.
After more than two decades, most serious theories about what happened to Branson Perry involve people he knew through drugs.
“I can tell you that there were a lot of people that were involved in the drug community … involved in selling,” said Darren White, a Nodaway County Sheriff’s deputy in 2001 and later sheriff from 2009 to 2017. “And there were a whole bunch of them that, they were all familiar with each other.”
According to Fanning’s book, Crawford told investigators that she and Perry used marijuana and amphetamines.
In rumors and anonymous tips over the years, a certain house situated on a gravel road about a mile east of Quitman that was a popular place to buy drugs kept coming up.
In fact, White said that witnesses at the time gave statements to investigators that placed Perry at the house after he had left his home in Skidmore, though White said he was not involved in the investigation itself at the time those statements were received.
Instead, he told The Forum in an interview last month that he was the deputy on duty when the house burned down.
Although he cautioned that he wasn’t sure of the exact sequence of events — and neither was Whittington — White said that he was sure that when the house burned down, Perry had not yet been reported missing.
To the best of his recollection, he said the fire took place sometime during the five days between the last time Crawford saw Perry at his home on Wednesday and when Perry’s family reported him missing on Monday — probably Friday or Saturday night, he said.
“There was a lot of activity that went on out there,” White said. But by the time of the fire, “they had all abandoned the place — and this was, in retrospect, after Branson went missing but before that was reported.” On that Friday or Saturday night, White said he responded to the fire at the house. “By the time that we got the call and got there, there was absolutely nothing left,” he said. “It had burned to the ground.”
And that, White said, is the most likely answer to what happened to Perry.
“The best theory is that house is where he was actually murdered,” White said. “That’s the best theory, that he was murdered in that house and that, ultimately, of course, when the house was destroyed by fire, any possible evidence that might have been there would have been destroyed in the fire.”
The house has featured prominently in rumors over the years as well, and in April 2019, Nodaway County Sheriff Randy Strong told the St. Joseph News-Press that Perry was last seen on April 11, 2001, at a residence that burned down only days later. Strong confirmed to The Forum this week that he was referring to a house in Quitman based on evidence gathered before he became sheriff. He said he did not want to share more for fear of putting someone in danger due to the specificity of the information.
Even if investigators believed that Perry was last seen at the house, that doesn’t solve the crime, White cautioned.
In the more than two decades that the case has been open, law enforcement officials have followed hundreds of leads that have all, so far, failed to lead to finding Perry.
Without that, there has never been enough to warrant an arrest.
“There was just a lot of little pieces of information, but not enough to put everything together,” White said.
TIPS WANTED
The Nodaway County Sheriff’s Office asks anyone with information about the Branson Perry case to contact them at 660-582-7451.
Other leads
The first major, public lead in the case came when authorities said they were investigating Jack Wayne Rogers, a Fulton, Missouri, man who was arrested in 2002 as part of the FBI’s Operation Candyman, a nationwide child pornography dragnet. Rogers was ultimately convicted in 2004 of multiple felonies in federal court including charges related to child pornography and assault.
The details of Rogers’ crimes are gruesome, and while police were looking into the child pornography allegations against Rogers, they found messages he had sent another user on a message board that seemed to describe his coming across a hitchhiker matching Perry’s description and raping, torturing and mutilating him before murdering him and burying him in a remote area of the Ozarks, according to news reports. According to Fanning’s book, law enforcement also found a turtle-shell necklace among Rogers’ possessions that resembled one owned by Perry.
However, Rogers maintained that his messages were only a fantasy, and that he had never encountered Perry. Klino, Perry’s mother, came to believe him, and Rogers was never charged in connection with the Perry case.
Other leads through phone calls and anonymous tips led to periodic searches and digs from Burlington Junction to Quitman over the years.
“There were a lot of tips, and how do you determine what’s credible and what’s not credible?” White said. “But they took everything pretty serious and there were a lot of people that spent a lot of time looking in wells and ponds and just all kinds of places and in several counties. It never went anywhere.”
But that never stopped law enforcement from trying again when a tip, any tip, would come in.
“One time it was reported that he was put in a barrel and they threw him in the river,” White recounted. “And there was a report that he was buried and then dug up and reburied multiple times. And then at one point there was a report that he was buried under a bridge and nothing ever came of that.
“So, you know, here we are all these years later and it’s just, it’s pretty frustrating.”
In 2009, while White was sheriff, his office conducted a two-day dig at a well in Quitman, following up on a tip received from a prisoner in Holt County who had told authorities that he was present when Perry was buried there.
“And we dug — oh boy did we dig,” White said. “We dug deep and never found anything then. And then later on, he recanted and said that he really didn’t know, that he just saw it as an opportunity to get out of jail for a while.
“But there again, you know, you get these tips and you can’t just ignore them.”
After the 2009 dig, leads were slow in coming, with no major new developments until 2022, when Strong told the News-Press that his agency had a suspect in the case, but lacked the evidence to bring charges without Perry’s body.
Then, widespread interest in the case and hope for new evidence were reignited when the sheriff’s office, acting on a “credible tip,” staked out another well in Quitman for a week last month, bringing in the FBI to assist with a search connected with the case. Ultimately, that lead turned up nothing, too.
“This is still an open case,” Capt. Austin Hann of the sheriff’s office said at the time. “So, the investigation portion of this never really stops for us. We are still gonna take every single tip in. We’re going to follow up on every single tip that’s provided and if we believe that that tip is credible, we’re going to pour resources into following up.”
As time has gone on, though, fewer and fewer people are still alive who might know what happened, and Perry’s close family, too, have passed away. His father, Bob, died in 2004, and his mother, Becky Klino, in 2011. His grandmother, Jo Ann Stinnett, died in 2015.
“The sad part is that his mother and his grandmother have both passed,” White said. “So I guess in some way they’re now with him and so they do have their final answer, for people that are of faith. But while they were both living, they really devoted a lot of time to trying to get some answers and some resolution.
“But it just never happened.”

SUBMITTED PHOTO
Darren White said he was the deputy on duty in 2001 when a call came in about a house near Quitman burning down. White also served as Nodaway County Sheriff from 2009-2017.

FORUM FILE PHOTO
Authorities in 2009 performed a two-day dig at a well in Quitman after receiving a tip from a Holt County prisoner who led them to where he said Branson Perry was buried, according to Darren White, who was Nodaway County sheriff at the time. White said the prisoner later recanted, saying he just wanted some time out of the jail while he led deputies to the spot while awaiting a transfer to the Department of Corrections.

PHOTOS COURTESY OF BRINGBRANSONHOME.WORDPRESS.COM
Branson Perry is shown at different stages in his life. The young man went missing in 2001 and has never been found. The case recently saw renewed interest when the Nodaway County Sheriff’s Office received a tip.
