Skip to content

Forum Editorial: MSHSAA should move private schools to own class

EDITORIAL MUG: Editorial art Vertical

In the (very) old days, before the Missouri State High School Activities Association, it was the students who would set up games with their counterparts at other schools. So at least we can all agree it’s probably best that they don’t have to make travel arrangements and figure out scheduling in between algebra and science class anymore.

That’s because 98 years ago this very week, the brainchild of our own Uel Lamkin, president of what would become Northwest Missouri State University, became reality when participating schools approved the constitution for the very first statewide organization to oversee interscholastic athletics: what would later become MSHSAA.

Over the ensuing decades things have gotten more…complicated, shall we say. More than 750 schools are part of the organization now, represented by a sprawling patchwork of administrators and activities directors that make up innumerable cliques with varying agendas. More often than not, they work together to try and come up with equitable solutions to whatever problems come before them. But like any large committee, some problems just get tossed around and around and talked about over and over that by the time everyone agrees on an acceptable facsimile of a horse, it looks to everybody else more like a pterodactyl than a camel.

That’s probably the most charitable explanation for how MSHSAA’s membership schools overwhelmingly voted to implement “championship factor” starting in 2020.

Normally, schools are divided into classes by MSHSAA based on enrollment that then determines who they compete against in state tournaments. Does it make for the most competitive matchups year in and year out? No, but people like Uel Lamkin and everybody who has come after agreed that enrollment is the fairest way to do it because if two school districts have similar enrollments, then, hey, maybe they’ll have around the same number of kids interested in each activity. And the more there are, the likelier that some of them will probably be pretty good! So enrollment it is.

Except for private schools.

Private schools, of course, don’t have to deal with inconveniences like district boundaries. So their enrollments aren’t as likely to have any correlation to what their sports teams are like — they can have exactly as many students as they want to have, no more or less. And if that happens to work out to a few stacked rosters year after year, well….

What schools across the state have done, then, is try and address what they agree is an inherent advantage available to private schools, which aren’t limited to students in their immediate area. In 2020, that took the form of “championship factor,” which moves private schools up a class in individual sports if they have success in state tournaments.

So, for example, if a private school placed in the final four of a state tournament in football at any point over the past six years, they’d move up a class for football. But if their baseball team had no such success, the baseball team would still be in the class that corresponded to their enrollment.

The idea was that this was a much fairer system than the one it replaced, which itself was made as a compromise: the previous system just multiplied every private school’s enrollment by 1.35 to try and mitigate the advantage. At least championship factor had some sort of competitive reasoning behind it.

Really, though, none of that is important, because both the enrollment multiplier and championship factor — and any other convoluted solution or potential solution — misses the point entirely:

Do we have schools attached to sports teams? Or do we have sports teams attached to schools?

Every public school is divided in their class based on enrollment. We could have split them up any way we wanted, we could have divided them up by their past success or any other metric we wanted, and we still can. But enrollment is how it works.

That’s because public schools are very much schools with sports teams. If MSHSAA’s mandate was to create a sports league that maximized competitiveness, then there’d be a lot more to change than championship factor. But that’s not the point of high school sports.

We believe the only real, truly equitable way forward is to create a private school class for state tournaments.

Yes, we acknowledge that many have been afraid in the past of the consequences — that some private schools may leave MSHSAA entirely and more actively and openly recruit talent away, or that it would throw some sports out of balance, or any number of protests.

And yes, we know that past efforts, as recently as a full membership vote in 2007, have not come close to being successful.

We believe high school sports are about more than winning and losing. But it makes no sense to have a team that is together because of geography face a curated team of kids from across a region or the state who made the cut. No, not every private school is like that, but not every public school is as good or bad as the other schools in their enrollment-based class either.

Why should the 85 percent of MSHSAA’s membership that’s made up of public schools continue to try and find ways to make sure teams of kids who made a conscious decision to go somewhere else still have the best possible competitive experience on the sports team they chose to join? What does that tell the 85 percent of kids in the state about how much they matter?

An enrollment multiplier, a championship factor, or some other solution — they’re all trying to reconcile the fact that there’s some rules made for everyone, and others made for everyone else. It doesn’t matter how many different ways we try it, there’s no way to make this look like a horse as long as it’s got wings and a beak — they just don’t belong to the same animal.

Yes, of course we want our kids to win, and they certainly do, too, but we know that more important than success on the field, court, or anywhere else, are the lessons we learn in our formative years about how to be a part of a team, how to deal with both failure and triumph, and how to handle ourselves with grace no matter the outcome. Sports in particular are where so many young people learn how to push themselves to new heights and forge their own identities.

Whether you were a part of a winning team that found tremendous success or a team that holds onto the memory of that one time you won, the feelings of camaraderie, self-discovery and youthful fun of participating in high school sports are hopefully what make that experience remain a nostalgic highlight for every kid who inevitably grows up. And in the end, those lessons and memories don’t require winning anything at all.

But right now, by continuing to cater to the needs of private schools, the only lesson our kids are learning is that a privileged few with the money and influence to write their own rules will always get every advantage they can grab — and too many others will be more than happy to ensure they get the chance.

… You know what, forget the whole thing. Maybe kids are learning exactly what they need to learn after all.

Leave a Comment