Garnering Insight: AI in the newsroom

Garnering Insight: AI in the newsroom
There are only a few things artificial that I like — one is sweetener and the other is a Christmas tree. I’ll tell you some artificial things that I don’t like — turf and intelligence.
Artificial intelligence can do many things, but count me as being on the side of caution in terms of when and how to apply the ever-involving technology of AI.
Is AI a useful tool? Absolutely. But not in the journalism profession.
Here at the Maryville Forum and Grant City Times-Tribune, we will not be using artificial intelligence to write stories. If it’s important, we will write it ourselves.
Those in favor of using AI in the field of newsgathering and writing would say that my stance is self-serving or self-preserving, and while that may be a byproduct of my viewpoint, it is certainly not the chief reason.
Proponents of utilizing AI in newspapers would say that you can cut staff, cover more stories and that everything would take less time and make more of a profit. To those who think that, I respect their right to have that opinion, but they are just plain wrong. Those of us actually in the business of local journalism could not be more against this technology.
Why? Answer this question:
Would you trust AI to write your loved one’s obituary? I think not. Therefore, I wouldn’t trust it to write a basic brief. If it’s not good enough for my grandma, it’s definitely not good enough to be in the newspaper.
Some have argued that using AI can make for a faster, more efficient writing process. It may be faster, but is it more efficient? I think not. You still have to fact check because these programs are scouring the internet for the information, and we all know that if it’s on the world wide web, it must be correct, insert sarcasm here.
Using these “tools” over the trained journalists who are rooted in our communities is not a good idea.
Let’s take a city council meeting or a school board meeting for example. Can AI take basic facts garnered from minutes those organizations post online? Certainly, but can it read the temperature of the room during a crucial vote? Definitely not! It also cannot describe the comments from the public or the banter from elected officials. AI cannot offer context and does not capture the human element of a story.
Let’s move on to sports.
We all know here in Nodaway and Worth counties that we are spoiled by the immense coverage in the pages of the Maryville Forum each week thanks to the extreme commitment to area youth by Jon Dykstra and his staff.
So can AI write a sports story based off a box score?
Sort of. It most certainly can regurgitate basic facts, figures and statistics, but it can’t relate the pivotal moment or a turning point in a game.
AI also can take things in a weird direction. I read an AI-generated high school sports story recently where one of the teams’ mascots was the Jets. In the story were weird references to airplane nomenclature for no specific reason and went off on aviation tangents.
To be honest, it was good for a laugh, but wouldn’t you hate if that were your son or daughter’s team and that was the coverage you got of their game?
Another issue with using AI in the newspaper is, how do we verify that the information generated by AI is actually true?
Let’s use the column in today’s paper by Friend of the Forum Frank Grispino. If Frank was not a specialist I trusted, how would I know that the information he presented in his partially AI-generated column is accurate?
Let me give you a non-newspaper recent example. In an acceptance speech at the Wall Street Journal Innovator Awards, Julia Louis-Dreyfus used AI to write her remarks, and it was riddled with errors and inconsistencies. It also confused her with Julia Roberts in her own speech and frequently interchanged the word innovator with investor. I think the Seinfeld and Veep star’s point was that people are the true creators of content, not a computer-generated app.
Thankfully, readers of the Maryville Forum and Grant City Times-Tribune will not be subjected to AI-generated content by staffers of the newspaper to write stories, recaps or briefs. Newspapers are a public trust and we work every day to uphold that trust and our standards — and there is nothing artificial about that.
Ken Garner is the owner and publisher of The Maryville Forum and The Post.
