Pearls: Motivated by greed, not by storytelling

EDITORIAL MUG: Matt Pearl
In the late 1990s, I got excited when the news came out that the Star Wars franchise would resume movie production, that George Lucsa was going to produce the prequel trilogy to the orignal 1970s/1980s saga that I had grown up loving.
And it was fine. Not great, but fine.
Then it really started happening: Indiana Jones got a sequel (and then another one a few months ago). Terminator got a second movie in the 90s, then more in the 2000s.
The Lord of the Rings made it to a movie adaptation, as did the Marvel Comics stories I had enjoyed reading as a kid.
It felt like Hollywood had my nerdy life all figured out: Make enough Star-this and Wizard-that and Matt will buy the ticket. I saw The Return of the King three times in the theater – two of those times by myself. Those were awesome (if not a bit lonely) days.
Then all the franchise giants – the iconic adventure films of my life – saw their stories begin to be told on an even more exciting medium: the streaming video service. And they were, in a word –
Lame.
You see, as it turns out, you can overproduce good ideas to the point where it becomes pretty clear that an epic story has become a cash cow for the major entertainment giants. Once a good story becomes salable, Hollywood’s finest idiots always buy into the same two fallacies: that more is always better, and there’s no way to overdo a good idea.
But what about when one of the streaming services takes the J.R.R.Tolkien universe of The Lord of the Rings and The Hobbit and decides to use the races and characters of Middle Earth to create stories that do not appear in the author’s works? The man wrote thousands of pages of ideas, but a room full of marketing geniuses miss the point – that people love good storytelling over volume of episodes.
Don’t get me started on Marvel or Star Wars. Those streaming TV adaptations are mediocre at best.
Now for those of you who I have lost, those who don’t enjoy the sci-fi/superhero/sword and sorcery genres of entertainment, I offer my apologies. I have a more general point to make here, and I’ll get to it now.
Commercial success motivated production companies to create new content. But creativity makes the content worth watching. If the almighty dollar becomes the only consideration, and increased production quantity becomes the only object, the the quality of entertainment goes down.
I love to write this column, but one per week is plenty. I suppose under duress I could hammer out a few more, but I don’t just have endless ideas. As some point, the quantity of writings would overshadow the quality of ideas, and the project would suffer.
One of my college professors, Dr. David Slater, encouraged his students to specialize, to gain a deep understanding of their tru academic passion. His rationale was that no one can get incredibly knowledgeable about everything, but that we could all delve deeply into one area of interest and become experts in the subject.
In other words, it’s better to do one thing really well than to try to take on too many things and risk turning in a mediocre performance. (Yes, I read that as I wrote it; no, the irony is not lost on me. But since it’s written, I won’t delete it.)
When entertainment became a game of producing as many movies or TV episodes of something while its popularity was high, the quality of the shows and motion pictures suffered.
In 1983, when it looked like George Lucas might have just made his final Star Wars film ever, I felt a tremendous loss. I wanted to know more about the story, to learn about the characters I had met as a young watcher of the movies.
Now, 40 years later, I wished he had ended it then. Nothing could be worse than watching some of my favorite stories ruined by studios who are motivated by greed – and who don’t care a lick about storytelling.
Matt Pearl owns and operates The Tri-County Ledger.
