Pearls: Now’s the time to use critical thinking

EDITORIAL MUG: Matt Pearl
It was your average week in American news: a celebrity death, a mass shooter who had been previously reported as being unhinged, and a somewhat inexplicably divided American opinion on Hamas killing Israelis at a rave.
And….cue the debates on everything.
Because nothing just happens anymore. It happens, news agencies respond with competitive, aggressive desires to report the story first (not best), and the patron watchers/listeners/readers for each individual news agency take their favorite outlet’s view on the matter.
As Marshall McLuhan warned us nearly 60 years ago, ‘The medium is the message.’ We have surrendered any semblance of impartiality in news reporting to our own vanity. Yes, our vanity – for it is our collective (and individual) choices to pick our news channel over our news accuracy that has created so much of our national turmoil.
Not to mention we have all voluntarily given Google and Facebook and Amazon such keen perspectives into our thought processes that ‘Big Tech’ has begun to know more about us than we know about ourselves. We buy things, we click things, we use keyboards over and over again in our social media posts – and now giant corporations are able to predict our buying and voting and thinking habits with terrifying accuracy.
My question is simple: ‘What do we do now?’
I won’t ask whether we should have embraced social media. Many of us who use it daily wish we had never seen it.
I won’t ask whether or not you believe the ads on your news feed seem to be reading your mind, or if it feels at times that your phone might be listening to your conversations. I already know that answer.
I won’t ask whether or not it has occurred to you, when you saw that brick-and-mortar store downtown close its doors, that your shopping online is what closed your neighbor’s business.
Because I know what you’ll say to any of those. We are not failing right now because we cannot see the problem. We are failing because seeing the problem we choose not to act upon our observations.
So again, ‘What do we do now?’
I’m not an economist, nor am I a socialist. I have, however, formed a handful of observations based upon my life experiences.
First, we need to determine the composition of our communities with our purchasing habits. If you want a business to stay in your community, then patronize it. Pay a little more to keep your money at home – and then let’s hold one another to doing the same.
Get your news from multiple sources. Everything is biased, but some outlets work harder than others to maintain more impartiality. Try to remember that a newscast that agrees with your views all the time will also possess your imperfections – vanity doesn’t further anyone’s quest for wisdom.
Use social media like a 90-year-old might: to see pictures of the family. Connect with people but avoid descending into political and social unrest by crusading bravely behind your keyboard.
We cannot spend our lives pining for the good ole days, because no matter how good we remember those days being, they were never perfect. By the same token, we ought never to set a torch to our traditions just for the sake of change. The free people of this country should be collectively smart enough to keep the best portions of the past, weed out the mistakes, and build a better tomorrow.
Don’t, as the expression states, throw out the baby with the bathwater. Just because something was done years ago doesn’t mean it’s necessarily antiquated – nor does it mean that the past is always right.
Now is the time for each of us to use that critical thinking that our teachers warned us we would need to apply sometime down the road. Well, sometime is now, and we are sufficiently down the road and in need of critical problem solving. Let’s do better, huh?
Matt Pearl owns and operates The Tri-County Ledger.
