Skip to content

Pearls: Social media: A playground for misinformation

EDITORIAL MUG: Matt Pearl

Our nation has seen – for the good or for the bad – the age of railroads pass. But that doesn’t mean we don’t witness our share of online train wrecks.

The worst come when uninformed folks decide to tackle important public issues on social media, and a single inflammatory post can become a playground for ignorance and misinformation.

You have read them, i’m sure: the posts, usually on a group or membership-type page, where somebody doesn’t understand his tax bill, or another doesn’t like the slide at the park, or somebody doesn’t know what’s going on a the public school – and so that individual’s complaint becomes an eyesore on Facebook. Defenders of the city or school jump in, opponents join the fight, and before long the post is so filled with misinformation that there’s no turning back.

And the worst part: the people who know the answer to the question, the individuals who possess the information to explain the problem, also have the sense not to try to fix public opinion on social media.

Read closely, folks, because this is the truth of it:

Social media is where the age of information took its final breath. When everyone gets to post like an expert, and the actual experts know to stay off of Facebook, you have an information vacuum in the spot where truth used to reside.

If you want to change your city, call your mayor or clerk and get on the council docket for the next meeting. Organize your ideas, explain your plan and respect the people around you. You might just get your way.

If you want to criticize your city, never see any meaningful change, build resentment toward your leaders and lock arms with other folks who have no intention of picking up a shovel or informing themselves in any way, then by all means, throw you ill-aimed grievances at Facebook.

What happened to calling someone who could answer your questions? Why keep a mayor or council if you’re intending to run the town from your iPhone?

I’m aiming broadly here. If you think I’m talking specifically about your town, I assure you that I am. But not just your town. It’s happening in every community everywhere. Facebook has become a suggestion box – not the closed, locked, slotted box where folks wrote their grievances, but a wide-open error-filled gripe session that’s on the internet for everyone to see.

And what’s more, the whole show becomes so entertaining that folks who would never post their rantings on such a forum check back on the post every couple of hours to see what terrible things people get brave enough to say to one another from behind a keyboard.

When this all happens – and we have all seen it happen dozens of times – what gets better? How often do we see things improve? What’s likelier to happen is that the people in charge – the folks who restrain themselves from posting on the issue at all – end up resenting the folks who are doing the complaining, and nothing productive follows.

So if our aim is to argue, then we’re winning. If our desire is to enact positive change and have our questions answered, why not just, I don’t know, engage our leaders? Our towns are small; it’s not tough to get the mayor on the phone.

Or, even better, we could take time when we get aggravated, think about things, collect a little information and cool down before we start blowing our horns online or at a meeting. Information is like a lamp: it reveals the truth of what’s actually happening, and prevents us from trying to discern policy in the dark.

And maybe we should remember that social media was designed to be social (if you forget, it’s right in the name). If it were created to be civic media, then we would call it that.

Or, if you prefer, I guess keep reading half-truths and misinformation on social media posts. If it’s a train wreck ye seek, then I guarantee it will be a train wreck ye shall find.

Matt Pearl owns and operates The Tri-County Ledger.

Leave a Comment